Re: including gregorian.ly breaks lyrics alignment in melismas

[Janek Warchoł]

2010/12/27 Xavier Scheuer <address@hidden>:
> 2010/12/27 Janek Warchoł <address@hidden>:
>>
>> including gregorian.ly breaks horizontal spacing when there are lyrics. 
>> Example:
>>
>> \include "gregorian.ly"
>> <<
>>        \new Voice = foobar { f'( a' g' f') }
>>        \new Lyrics \lyricsto foobar \lyricmode { lalah }
>> >>
>
> Hi!
>
> I compiled with 2.13.43 and I did not see an issue here.
>
> The result is exactly the same if we comment  \include "gregorian.ly" ,
> so this tends to mean if there is an issue it is not due to this.
>
> I suppose you consider an issue the fact that the syllable is
> left-aligned instead of horizontally centered below the first note.
> This is due to the slur and is normal behaviour AFAIK.
> The slur is creating a melismata and LilyPond tries to horizontally
> center the syllable below the whole slurred passage.  But it needs to
> stay below the first note also (because that's where the syllable begins),
> so it is left-aligned.
> Seems "normal" to me, so not an issue here IMHO.

This surely sounds like normal bahaviour! Looks like i'm getting
different output than you do. I attach my output.
(in addition to strange alignment, including gregorian.ly causes the
indent to disappear on my computer)...
I'm using LilyPond 2.13.43 (i'll install .44 right now) on Windows 7
Professional PC.

cheers,
Janek

with gregorian.png
Description: PNG image

without gregorian.png
Description: PNG image