Re: New easymenu behavior

[David Ponce]

> > > What does your code do that did not already break in Emacs 21.3?
> >
> > recentf simply uses (easy-menu-add-item nil '("files") ...) to add
> > the recentf menu into the "File" menu which is identified with the
> > 'files key symbol. This worked well in 21.3 because the code just
> > interned "files" to get the key symbol.
>
>
> That appears very shaky.

I agree.

> > Notice that XEmacs directly use menu item names to locate them.  For
> > example you can use '("File") to locate the "File" menu in the menu
> > bar. Maybe is it a better mechanism to use in external libraries?
>
>
> Actually, that is all that I ever used with regard to easymenu.  It is
> probably a bad idea to create and manage menus by a mixture of direct
> accesses and easymenu.

recentf only uses easymenu not a mixture of direct access and easymenu.

How do you tell easy-menu-add-item to use menu item names instead of 
internal names?  The following works with XEmacs but not with Emacs:

(easy-menu-add-item
 nil
 '("File")
 '("Submmenu"
   ["item1" ignore]
   ["item2" ignore]))

In Emacs it replaces all the "File" menu items with "Submenu", and 
create another empty "File" entry in the menu bar.

But the following works as expected.

(easy-menu-add-item
 nil
 '("Files")
 '("Submmenu"
   ["item1" ignore]
   ["item2" ignore]))