Re: make dist target for Windows

[Christoph]

On 4/4/2010 1:10 AM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
> You set distFilesOk here, but you never unset it before exiting the
> script.
>    
Missed one. Fixed.

> Hmm... did you try running "make dist" with some sh.exe on your PATH?
> I think it's not a good idea to rely on a Unixy shell to know how to
> run Windows batch files.  I would suggest to invoke through the
> Windows shell explicitly:
>
>         $(COMSPEC) /c $(ARGQUOTE)zipdist.bat $(DQUOTE)$(INSTALL_DIR)$(DQUOTE) 
> $(VERSION)$(ARGQUOTE)
>
> The $(*QUOTE) stuff is needed in case $(INSTALL_DIR) includes spaces,
> but please test that this works, both with cmd.exe and sh.exe as the
> shell, because I didn't.
>    
I tried this but it doesnt work, neither with a shell (cygwin) or cmd.exe:

$(ComSpec) /c $(ARGQUOTE)zipdist.bat $(DQUOTE)$(INSTALL_DIR)$(DQUOTE) 
$(VERSION)$(ARGQUOTE)

(Note the camelcase-ing of ComSpec which is necessary for Windows NT to 
find cmd.exe. The makefile has a couple of paragraphs on this topic in 
the NOTES section at the top.)

However, I get the following error in both scenarios:

Using Cygwin, mingw32:
C:\Windows\system32\cmd.exe /c 'zipdist.bat 
"D:/devel/emacs/emacs-bzr/makedistw32/nt/.." 24.0.50'
devel was unexpected at this time.
mingw32-make: *** [dist] Error 255

Using Cmd.exe, GNU coreutils. mingw32:
C:\Windows\system32\cmd.exe /c "zipdist.bat 
\"D:/devel/emacs/emacs-bzr/makedistw32/nt/..\" 24.0.50"
devel was unexpected at this time.
mingw32-make: *** [dist] Error 255

Remove $(DQUOTE) and it works fine in both cases, but this will cause 
trouble if $(INSTALL_PATH) contains spaces.

Here is my preliminary final version:

    $(COMSPEC)$(ComSpec) /c $(ARGQUOTE)zipdist.bat $(INSTALL_DIR) 
$(VERSION)$(ARGQUOTE)

This will work fine with the cygwin shell and Windows PreNT/NT cmd.exe 
as long as $(INSTALL_DIR) does not contain any spaces.

However, is the rest of the makefile capable of handling this case 
correctly? I see $(INSTALL_DIR) quoted in some places, some don't have 
quotes. The NOTES section of the makefile says that quoting helps making 
the forward slashes work in cmd.exe. It does not mention the support of 
spaces in file names.

Any ideas?

Christoph