Re: [Emacs-diffs] /srv/bzr/emacs/trunk r100117: Run kill-emacs when exiting for display closed or SIGTERM/HUP.

[Stefan Monnier]

>>>>> For this bug report, yes.  But for the more general session management
>>>>> handling, it really is "start where we stopped".
>>>> But that's the whole problem: what do you define as "where we stopped"?
>>>> As I said, there are as many current directories as there are buffers.
>>> Yes there is, it is what getcwd returns.  That is where the process is
>>> started.
>> A far cry from "where we stopped".

> No, according to the OS, that is exactly where the process current directory
> is when we stop.  Where do you say the process current directory is when
> Emacs stops?

What I say is that users couldn't care less what's the POSIX cwd of
Emacs (as long as it's sane, that is).

> A file dialog can remember where it was when closed last, and by default
> show that directory again.  That doesn't mean that the process now has two
> current directories.

You're suggesting a user-level feature (a new command line arg) based on
some obscure internal detail.  That doesn't make much sense unless
there's no other way to get the user-level behavior you want.

> internally. Restarting Emacs in the same directory as it stopped always
> work, but just pointing out a desktop file does not.  For example, the
> directory remembered by *scratch* is not restored.

The --chdir is not enough to restore the default-directory of all the
buffers either.  So if you want to preserve that info, then add
`default-directory' to desktop-locals-to-save rather than try to get
that same result in a round about way by adding a new vaguely related
feature which doesn't quite do what we want anyway.

>>>>> Who knows what other/future packages save in the current directory?
>>>> There's really no such thing as "Emacs's current directory".
>>> Yes there is, it is what getcwd returns.  Anything else is just cosmetics
>>> and not the current directory of the Emacs process.
>> In which way is this getcwd data relevant/useful?

> It is where Emacs was started, it is where Emacs was stopped, and thus where
> Emacs should be restarted.

Why?  Why would a user care?

> Where else should Emacs be restarted?

Doesn't matter as long as the end result is the one we want.
Usually I'd expect $HOME to be a good choice.

> I don't understand, why would we ever want Emacs to restart in a different
> directory than where it stopped?  You claim there is a bunch of directories
> to choose from, so we should just give up and not do anything?

Exactly, because that cwd doesn't matter to Emacs (and by extension to
Emacs's users).


        Stefan