Re: [O] (org-insert-headline '(4)) should insert new headline before point

[Eric Abrahamsen]

Leonard Randall <address@hidden> writes:

> Sorry, I should clarify that the C-RET functions as expected in the
> content of an entry, it is only problematic when it is called from
> the headline.
> All best,
> Leonard

Yes, please, this has gotten really difficult to use all of a sudden!
New headings are inserted between the old heading and the old heading's
PROPERTIES drawer, which seems very wrong...

> On 23 April 2014 22:42, Leonard Randall <address@hidden>
> wrote:
>
>     Hi Bastien,
>     I just wanted to report an issue with this fix. In many use cases
>     it makes C-RET less useful, and renders the speedkeys command `i'
>     useless. It makes C-RET function much like M-RET, and it makes
>     `i' insert headlines before any content.
>    
>     So if I call C-RET in the middle of the following headline:
>     ---
>     ** Important Meeting
>     SCHEDULED: <2014-04-26 Sat 16:30>
>     headline content...
>     ---
>     I get:
>     ---
>     ** Important
>    
>     ** Meeting
>     SCHEDULED: <2014-04-26 Sat 16:00>
>     headline content...
>     ---
>     And when I use the speedkeys command `i' at the beginning, I get
>     ---
>     ** Important Meeting
>    
>     **
>     SCHEDULED: <2014-04-26 Sat 16:00>
>     headline content...
>     ---
>     Both of these break the scheduling cookie and defeat the main
>     purpose of these commands.
>    
>     Reverting the change restores expected behavior in these cases,
>     but then I suppose we are left with York's problem.
>    
>     All best,
>     Leonard
>    
>    
>     On 22 April 2014 10:23, Bastien <address@hidden> wrote:
>    
>         Hi York,
>        
>         thanks for coming back to this.
>        
>         York Zhao <address@hidden> writes:
>        
>         > What I meant was that with one prefix argument, the command
>         > `org-insert-heading' should insert a new heading *before*
>         the
>         > current heading, not after.
>        
>         Actually, this has little to do with the prefix argument:
>         when
>         at the beginning of a heading or a list item, M-RET should
>         add
>         a new heading/item *before* the current heading/item.
>        
>         This is fixed now, thanks for reporting this,
>        
>         PS: Using C-u M-RET will force
>         `org-insert-heading-respect-content'
>         to `t', i.e. add the headline at the end of the subtree.  As
>         Nicolas
>         noted, this is the same than C-RET.
>        
>         --
>          Bastien
>        
>    
>