[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Elisp lexical-let
From: |
Ken Raeburn |
Subject: |
Re: Elisp lexical-let |
Date: |
Wed, 22 Jul 2009 16:50:49 -0400 |
On Jul 22, 2009, at 05:11, Daniel Kraft wrote:
It seemed really hard to me to find at least *basic* information
about how the lexbind things works; I did build now an emacs with
lexbind from trunk, but so far as I see this is not meant to
implement "lexical-let" as the cl package does, but rather allows
switching all bindings from dynamic to lexical within one source file.
Oh... I may have seriously misunderstood; sorry about that. That's
what comes from not having bothered to look. :-)
In that case, the cl package is probably the thing to look at for now;
it is used by a bunch of other things in Emacs. But I do expect
lexbind is going to get merged in eventually, so keeping that in mind
for the future would be wise too.
And checks with the cl package's implementation of lexical-let give
the result, that an inner let does the same as if it was another
lexical-let; that is, does not revert to dynamic binding but rather
sets only the lexical value.
So, what are the opinions regarding lexical-let as an extension
construct? Regarding the behaviour, to me the one described above
seems to be a consequence of the implementing with unwind-protect
and not necessarily expected -- thus I suggest to implement the
version I had in mind, namely that an inner let or argument binding
inside a lambda reverts to dynamic binding for that inner scope.
This seems more consistent and reasonable to me.
I think you could make an argument for doing it either way. The
interesting question would be whether anyone is depending on the
behavior from the cl package.
Ken
- Elisp lexical-let, Daniel Kraft, 2009/07/21
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Ken Raeburn, 2009/07/21
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Daniel Kraft, 2009/07/22
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Marijn Schouten (hkBst), 2009/07/22
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Daniel Kraft, 2009/07/22
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Marijn Schouten (hkBst), 2009/07/23
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Mark H Weaver, 2009/07/23
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Andy Wingo, 2009/07/23
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Daniel Kraft, 2009/07/23
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Marijn Schouten (hkBst), 2009/07/24
- Re: Elisp lexical-let,
Ken Raeburn <=
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Daniel Kraft, 2009/07/23
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Andy Wingo, 2009/07/23
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Daniel Kraft, 2009/07/24
- Re: Elisp lexical-let, Andy Wingo, 2009/07/23
Re: Elisp lexical-let, Andy Wingo, 2009/07/23