gwm-general
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[Gwm-general] lumberyard


From: Peggy York
Subject: [Gwm-general] lumberyard
Date: Sat, 16 Sep 2006 05:04:03 -0500

Where exactly does he stand, socially, morally, and politically? In BARNABY RUDGE it is acase of rioting rather than revolution.
In any case the central character isnot likely to be a coal-miner. The boys learnt with a good will, but whatdid they learn?
And needless to say, that is just the impression thatis intended.
The central action of Dickenssstories almost invariably takes place in middle-class surroundings.
An adventure storymust of its nature be more or less remote from real life. Chesterton and Jackson seem toimply, a proletarian writer. The central action of Dickenssstories almost invariably takes place in middle-class surroundings.
The boys learnt with a good will, but whatdid they learn?
Their general natureis obvious enough, and I do not want to discuss them. He even credits some of these wretches with a taste for guillotiningchildren.
Notice, for instance that touch, with their heads low down andtheir hands high up, etc. A change of heart is in fact THE alibi of peoplewho do not wish to endanger the STATUS QUO.
Dickenss thoughts seem to have come full circle. Once again, individualkindliness is the remedy for everything. Some of what Dickens says remains true eventoday.
Dickenss thoughts seem to have come full circle. The one, how can you improve human natureuntil you have changed the system?
Even the Reign of Terror was a muchsmaller thing than he makes it appear. They are all living at several pounds a weekabove their income. It isworth comparing him with Charles Reade, for instance.
From time to time astory appears which is ostensibly directed AGAINST snobbery.
Itand others like it show how deep was Dickenss horror of revolutionaryhysteria.
Consequently they are on thesurface much more realistic.
To begin with, the school story, always partly dependent onsnob-appeal, is by no means eliminated. The boys learnt with a good will, but whatdid they learn?
A change of heart is in fact THE alibi of peoplewho do not wish to endanger the STATUS QUO. Where exactly does he stand, socially, morally, and politically? Their general natureis obvious enough, and I do not want to discuss them. In other words, the French aristocracy had dug their own graves. To what extent people draw their ideasfrom fiction is disputable. For inreality his target is not so much society as human nature.
Notice, for instance that touch, with their heads low down andtheir hands high up, etc. The central action of Dickenssstories almost invariably takes place in middle-class surroundings. No doubt it was Doctor Blimbers curriculum, a littlewatered down.

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]