Bug or enhancement for the disposable editor

[Francisco Vila]

After reading and answering this message from -user, I think this user
is partially right:

The file name is Welcome_to_lilypond.ly and the user is asked to save
it in the Desktop. But there is a problem.

If you choose Save from the File menu, where is the file now? Not in
the Desktop.

Otherwise, If you choose Save As, the save dialog does not keep this
default name, the user can of course give it a name, but possibly not
being the default, we cannot ask her to open the PDF with the default
name as if this exact filename were typed down. Therefore, the user is
right when she does not find the PDF by default name.

As an additional small issue, the proposed minimal score reads
\relative { c d e ... which is deprecated, it should be \relative c' {
...


---------- Forwarded message ----------
(...)
> This
> happens no matter how often I follow rhe less-than-consistant
> instructions in the "ly" file, because the PDF it refers to as
> "Welcome_to_LilyPond.PDF" does not appear to exist.

If you have followed the steps 1 and 2, lilypond performs the step 3
creating this file.

I agree with you in a point: "File->Save" leaves the file with its
preset name in an unknown place, whereas "File->Save as" gets this
preset name lost and you'll have to write down your own name, do it,
please save the file as whatever.ly into the Desktop as step 1, then
follow the step 2 and you will obtain a PDF called whatever.pdf as
step 3.
(...)

-- 
Francisco Vila. Badajoz (Spain)
http://www.paconet.org