Re: collision between beem and rests

[James]

Hello,


On 6 Jan 2012, at 20:37, Werner LEMBERG <address@hidden> wrote:

>>> somehow I've believed that lilypond contains code to avoid
>>> collisions between beems and rests, but apparently this is not true
>>> or no longer true.
>>> 
>>> \relative c' <<
>>>   { \voiceOne c'8 r } \\
>>>   { \voiceThree c,8.[ c'16] }
>>>>> 
>>> 
>>> Am I missing something or is this a real bug?
>> 
>> Is this a 'valid' (i.e using voice 1 and 3 only) comparison?
> 
> I don't understand your question.  Please reformulate.


well I'm making the point that using different voices affects stem direction, 
and stem direction affects beams (obviously) so using two voices with the same 
stem direction when you are using two voices and voiceOne and voiceTwo doesn't 
cause this, nor does one two AND three.

If this is really two voices then why would you use stems in the same direction?

Else I'd argue this is in the same category as ties and slurs in different 
voices not terminating.

> 
>> 2.14.1 output attached
> 
> Well, I would like to have the rest over the beam...

can't use use an override and shift it?

James


> 
> 
>    Werner