Re: [Lilypond-auto] Issue 3150 in lilypond: oversight in repeats.itely with old bar-line-glyphs

[Marc Hohl]

[code.google.com doesn't let me use the html form to reply, I claims out 
that
address@hidden is an invalid owner username. Huh?]

Am 01.02.2013 09:20, schrieb address@hidden:
> Comment #2 on issue 3150 by address@hidden: oversight in repeats.itely 
> with old bar-line-glyphs
> http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=3150
>
> > git grep "|:" doesn't show it.
>
> It does here, but then I use bash as my shell.  With
> git grep '"|:"'
> I don't get to see it, obviously.
>
> Frankly, I don't think we are doing people a favor with ".|:" exactly 
> because it is an exclusively glyph-induces statement about the bar 
> line rather than a logical one.  There is no section ending before and 
> after every repeat logically.  Nobody views a repeat sign in that 
> manner, and if you write out, say, lyrics with repetition, you'd write
>
> |: I love you, :|: again and again :|.
>
> And you would not realize that the last bar is what you see in 
> mid-song also.  Or is it?
I am not sure that I understand you correctly.

Do you imply that the '.' kind of ends a section and should probably
be changed to another glyph which has no special meaning in terms
of sentences/sections and ideally looks like a bold vertical line, or am
I totally wrong here?