Re: Two Problems with a SATB-Choir Score

[Graham Percival]

On Fri, 01 Nov 2002 23:03:13 +0100
address@hidden (Ronald Hoellwarth) wrote:
> But: why did v1.4.12 choose to put the fermata on the bass part correctly
> under the note but v1.6.5 choose (wrongy) to put the fermata above the
> note into the realm of the tenor?
> 
> I told lilypond that the soprano is \VoiceOne, alto \VoiceTwo, tenor
> \VoiceOne and bass \VoiceTwo and thought therefore it should (as v1.4.12
> did it) place the fermata on the right side of the Staffs.
> 
> Was there a change between v1.4.12 and v1.6.5 in regard to the way it is
> considered where to place things like fermata?

Evidently there _was_ such a change.  The only question is whether the change
was intentional, or merely a bug that got introduced.  :)

If you send a short example that shows this behaviour, we could investigate
whether it's a bug or not.  (if you already sent an example, please resend
it; I can't remember if you did or not)

Cheers,
- Graham