Slur/Tie Ambiguity

[David Pounder]

Sorry - forgot to attach the pdf.

------- Original Message -------
From: David Pounder <address@hidden>
To: address@hidden
Sent: 4.4.09, 20:43:19
Subject: Slur/Tie Ambiguity

Good evening List,

The snippet below shows two c naturals tied across a barline, followed by a c 
natural slurred to a c sharp across a barline.

Lilypond makes both look identical. I think the first is right (born out by the 
NR) - but is the second?

I know I can force the sharp or add a cautionary with ! or ? but am puzzled by 
the behaviour.

Pdf output is attached.

\version "2.12.2"

\score {
 \new Staff \relative c'' {
 \time 4/4
 \key a \major

 r2. c4~ | c4 r2 c4 ( | cis ) r2. |
 }
 \layout { }
}

Regards,

David Pounder

Test-Tie.pdf
Description: Binary data