|
I think it's because the 2 clashing notes are in
the same voice, and therefore any shift would apply to each equally. Try
making your bassOneToTrebleTwo use voiceFour.
==
Phil Holmes
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, November 21, 2011 3:37
PM
Subject: Why can't I force an
hshift?
Hi!
I'm setting part 2 of BWV142 in a piano-vocal
version (Petrucci
PDF, p. 3), and am having trouble getting the voices to print correctly in
the piano part when they change staves. In 'bassOneMusic' below, the g at the
end of m6 and the fis beginning m7 should both be shifted a bit, but my use of
force-hshift is not having any effect.
What am I doing
wrong?
Thanks!
Fred
%%% extracted short
sample
\version "2.14.1"
bassOneToTrebleTwo = { \change Staff =
"treble" \voiceTwo }
trebleTwoToBassOne = { \change Staff = "bass"
\voiceOne }
hR = { \once \override NoteColumn #'force-hshift = #0.5
}
global = {
\key c\major
\time 4/4
\override Hairpin #'to-barline = ##f
\mergeDifferentlyDottedOn
}
trebleOneMusic = \relative c'''
{
a8 e fis a g!4 e4 ~ | % 6 % end sys 3
e dis e r | %
7
}
trebleTwoMusic = \relative c'' {
c8 c c b16 a b4 b | %
6 % end sys 3
c b <g b>8 e e e | % 7
}
bassOneMusic
= \relative c' {
e8 a, a a e'4 \bassOneToTrebleTwo \hR g | % 6 % end
sys 3
\hR fis2 \trebleTwoToBassOne e8 e d! [ c16 b ] | %
7
}
bassTwoMusic = \relative c' {
a4. g!16 fis g4. fis16 e
| % 6 % end sys 3
a8 [ g16 fis ] b8 b, e8 c' b [ a16 gis ] | %
7
}
\score {
<<
\new
PianoStaff <<
\new Staff = "treble"
\with {
%%% \override
RestCollision #'positioning-done =
#merge-rests-on-positioning
}
<<
\new Voice = "treble1"
<< \voiceOne \global \trebleOneMusic
>>
\new Voice = "treble2"
<< \voiceTwo \global \trebleTwoMusic
>>
>>
\new Staff = "bass" \with
{
%%% \override RestCollision
#'positioning-done =
#merge-rests-on-positioning
}
<<
\clef
bass
\new Voice = "bass1"
<< \voiceOne \global \bassOneMusic
>>
\new Voice = "bass2"
<< \voiceTwo \global \bassTwoMusic
>>
>>
>>
>>
\layout {
\context
{
\Staff
}
}
}
--
The things that make us happy make us
wise.
-- John Crowley, Little, Big
_______________________________________________
lilypond-user
mailing
list
address@hidden
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
|