Re: Removing Fingering_engraver

[Nick Payne]

On 17/02/13 09:59, Eluze wrote:
> Nick Payne-3 wrote
> > Just curious - the Internals Reference says that fingering is in the
> > Voice context, but when I remove it I still see fingering. I would have
> > expected the code below to remove the fingering, but it doesn't. I'd
> > like to be able to publish a fingered score without fingering for those
> > who prefer to work out their own. I also tried removing it from Score
> > and Staff contexts without the fingering disappearing:
> >
> > \version "2.17.12"
> >
> > \score {
> >       \relative c' {
> >           
> > <c-4>
> > 4
> >       }
> >       \layout {
> >           \context {
> >               \Voice
> >                   \remove "Fingering_engraver"
> >           }
> >       }
> > }
> there's also the New_fingering_engraver and one acts upon fingerings in a
> chord while the other is for fingerings outside a chord!
>
> you can add
>
> \remove New_fingering_engraver
>
> to get rid of all fingerings

Thanks, removing both engravers gets rid of all fingering. However, the 
behaviour of using either one or the other seems inconsistent. If I have

<c-4>4 c-4

then if I use

\remove "New_fingering_engraver"

it removes the fingering on the first C (i.e. the chord) and leaves the 
fingering on the second. If I use

\remove "Fingering_engraver"

it doesn't remove the fingering on either note. If I use both the 
\remove commands then it removes the fingering on both notes. So it 
seems one can remove the fingering from chorded notes, or from all 
notes, but not just from unchorded notes.