[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Interplay between keepWithTag and relative music
From: |
Patrick or Cynthia Karl |
Subject: |
Interplay between keepWithTag and relative music |
Date: |
Sun, 02 Mar 2014 15:39:36 -0600 |
So I guess I don't understand the subject interplay. Consider the following
minimal example:
\version "2.18.0"
A = \relative g' {
c c c c
\tag #'up { c' c c c }
\tag #'down { c, c c c }
c c c c
}
\score {
\keepWithTag #'up \A
}
Based on the description on p477 of the 2.18.0 Notation manual (Untagged music
and music tagged with name is included; music tagged with any other tag name is
excluded.), I would expect the pdf output of the above snippet to be the same
as that for:
\relative g' {
c c c c
c' c c c
c c c c
}
But that's not what I get. Instead it appears that the music tagged with
"down" is actually included to the extent that the music in the 3rd measure is
an octave lower than expected. Note, too, that an entirely different result is
obtained if the two \tag lines are interchanged.
I expect that all I need is a pointer to the appropriate documentation that
explains this.
- Interplay between keepWithTag and relative music,
Patrick or Cynthia Karl <=