RE: Separate pedal staff shifts notes in music staves

[Javier Ruiz-Alma]

>To reproduce the behaviour you just have to extend on staff

I'm not sure what to do with your suggestion.  My case doesn't involve
adding bars to the existing music line.  I have a parallel staff for pedal
and I'm changing the timing of a sustainOff event, which I wouldn't expect
to result in bar compression on the above music staves.
The snippet I sent behaves as I'd expect (i.e. no change), however, there is
change when I implement the same change to bar78 of the linked score.  I'm
trying to figure out what is interacting with pedal staff to cause this
behavior.
Thx,Javier


Am 02.06.2014 04:27, schrieb Javier Ruiz-Alma:
> I have Pedal markings on a separate 'dynamics" staff within a PianoStaff
>
>
> I need to place a sustainOff between 5th and 6th beats (on 6/4 time).
> If I place the sustainOff on the 5th beat, the 6 quarter notes in the bass
are kept at equal distances, however, if I place the sustainOff after the
5th beat, the note column of the 6th beat is shifted left.
>
> I'm attaching images of the typesetting:
>
> PedalStaff1.png (equal beat spacing when sustainOff placed on 5th beat):
> s1\sustainOn s4 s4\sustainOff
>
> PedalStaff2.png (compressed 6th beat when sustainOff placed after 5th
beat):
> {s1\sustainOn s8. s16\sustainOff s4}, or {s1\sustainOn s8 s8\sustainOff
s4}
>
> I tried to replicate with a tiny example, but I can't replicate this
shifting behavior :
>
> \version "2.18.2"
> \new PianoStaff
> <<
> \new Staff \relative c''{
> \time 6/4
> <<{ c2.( d2) d4 | c2.( d2) d4 | } \\
> { g,2. a | g2. a |}
>>>
> }
> \new Staff \relative c'{
> \clef bass
> c4( ees f,ees'g f)
> c4( ees f,ees'g f)
> }
> \new Dynamics {
> \time 6/4
> s1\sustainOn s4 s4\sustainOff
> s1\sustainOn s8. s16\sustainOff s4
> }
>>>
>
> The issue does occur in bar78 in the following score:
> https://gist.github.com/dominicus/8085e4d3e8692ca64d27
>
>
> Any ideas as to why a separate pedal staff may influence the note columns
in other staves?
>
>
> Javier Ruiz-Alma
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> lilypond-user mailing list
> address@hidden
> https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user