回复： Jianpu Notation

[Super-User]

Ming Tsang: I also expected it for long, and went for collage for a CS degree, and work in startups for two years, and try to write my own implementation.

>Note that I don't say that the output of a1soft program is optimal
>compared to manually printed jianpu scores.  But lilypond's output is

>still too different.

That's right, still far away to go yet.

>Comments in the code are not the documentation I am talking about.  The
>JianpuStaff should be added to the Internals Reference, and the
>documentation should be added to all of the languages of LilyPond
>documentation.

I have not downloaded the IR yet, but some other documents from the official website.

I can contribute my time writing decent documentation and examples the same way with other elements in notation.pdf , when it comes to final version that can produce industrial quality of Jianpu output.

David Zhang

------------------ 原始邮件 ------------------

发件人: "Carl Sorensen"<address@hidden>;

发送时间: 2015年4月23日(星期四) 晚上8:47

收件人: "Werner LEMBERG"<address@hidden>;

抄送: "Paul Morris"<address@hidden>; "MING TSANG"<address@hidden>; "Super-User"<address@hidden>; "lilypond-user"<address@hidden>;

主题: Re: Jianpu Notation

On 4/22/15 10:55 PM, "Werner LEMBERG" <address@hidden> wrote:

>
>>>Ok, the problem was that your music file was for LilyPond 2.19 and
>>>jianpu3.ly only works with 2.18.
>> 
>> Have you proposed adding this to LilyPond?  It seems like this would
>> be a promising thing to add to the core, since it's another standard
>> notation.
>
>But it's still *far* away from the look of normal jianpu notation as
>used e.g. for the Erhu in Taiwan.  Attached you can find a typical
>example, created with the a1soft program, together with a
>`translation' to lilypond.
>
>Note that I don't say that the output of a1soft program is optimal
>compared to manually printed jianpu scores.  But lilypond's output is
>still too different.

Ah, I see. the current output is a sketch of Jianpu, but not really Jianpu.

That's a good reason to have it available, but not in core.

Thanks,

Carl