Re: Slur over single note?

[Urs Liska]

Am 19. Juli 2016 20:02:10 MESZ, schrieb David Wright <address@hidden>:
>On Tue 19 Jul 2016 at 18:58:36 (+0200), Urs Liska wrote:
>> Am 19. Juli 2016 18:11:14 MESZ, schrieb "Joel C. Salomon"
><address@hidden>:
>> >On 2016-07-19 2:45 AM, tisimst wrote:
>> >> It could be a LaissezVibrer tie, but I'm wondering if there isn't
>a
>> >> connection to the next bar. The tie extends so far and touches the
>> >> BarLine at the end of that measure that makes me wonder, but it's
>> >only
>> >> speculation at this point. Given the ending tip's vertical
>position,
>> >> too, it almost looks like it could be a slur. What does the next
>bar
>> >> look like?
>> >
>> >The next bar doesn’t have any partial ties or slurs.  
>> 
>> But is there an a or any other note that could reasonably be tied or
>slurred to in the next measure?
>> 
>> From my experience as editor this really looks like a broken tie or
>slur where the engraver forgot to supply the second part. This happens
>extremely often.
>> 
>> Best would be an image of the next system.
>
>Attached. Every bar in the piece looks like the other three bars,
>except for two cadences at which beat 4 is a crochet in the bass.
>So IMHO it's to make sure the note is sustained right through the
>bar, as this movement lacks any pedalling. A tie here wouldn't make
>sense in the context.

Interestingly senseless, indeed.
I'm 98% sure that's an engraving error of some kind that may be resolved by 
analogy. I'd have to see the full score ...

Mind sending that (privately if you want) or a download link?

Urs
>
>As I said in the other subthread, not being a pianist, I don't know
>which hand plays the quavers in the upper staff and whether that has
>implications for sustaining the note.
>
>Cheers,
>David.

-- 
Diese Nachricht wurde von meinem Android-Mobiltelefon mit K-9 Mail gesendet.