Re: Counterpoint (was: request for programming advice)

[Frauke Jurgensen]

In short, yes, such things exist, though not in Lilypond. I am a computational musicologist that collaborates in developing tools for analysing counterpoint. We've got tools like this to use in Humdrum or Music21. I think the Lilypond implementation would not be trivial (as Urs says), but I'll talk to one of my colleagues who is a much better programmer and see what he says.

On Tue, Nov 8, 2016 at 9:57 AM, Urs Liska <address@hidden> wrote:

Am 07.11.2016 um 13:21 schrieb bart deruyter:
> On a sidenote (perhaps for a different topic), in Musescore there is
> the possibility to create plugins which provide harmony checks,
> someone also did a plugin for a previous Musescore version which
> checked only first species counterpoint.
>
> I know lilypond's first purpose is creating sheet music, not composing
> music, but are there snippets of scheme or libraries around which
> could do the same?
>
> I think, for people who study counterpoint and voice leading, or any
> other rule-set in music, it would be very interesting to have a an
> option to check if they've followed the rules. In my case I have no
> teacher, can't afford private lessons, so I have to figure it out on
> my own without any way to check if I'm actually correct in
> interpreting the rules and executing the exercises.
>

I don't know if any code for this or similar purposes is already around
(I suspect not, otherwise you'd have got a reply), but I think from the
organizational POV it should be pretty easy to write something like
that. Basically it would work similar to the part combiner: take two (or
more) music expressions, perform the calculation and produce some
output. I don't immediately see how the actual content checks would have
to be implemented, but the infrastructure should be striaghtforward.

I can see different ways to approach it: one could have a function that
simply performs the checks and prints out the results to the console, or
it could actually modify the music expressions in a way that the results
are printed directly in the score (e.g. coloring or other visible hints).
In a similar way one could also write functions for harmonic analysis.

Probably the actual implementation is not all that trivial, and I
wouldn't start working on it. But I think it would make a good
openLilyLib package, and if someone is interested in the topic and has
the necessary Scheme skills I'd be happy to help with the openLilyLib
part of things.

Urs

_______________________________________________
lilypond-user mailing list
address@hidden
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user