Re: Incorrect note alignment

[Brian Barker]

At 19:23 16/11/2016 +0100, Joram Noeck wrote:
> Still, I would not over-interpret Behind Bars. If Gould states it 
> explicitly: ok, but the examples are also done with some program, I 
> guess. In case there is a detail she does not care enough, there can 
> be cases where she accepts the program's default output without 
> saying that other solutions are necessarily bad or wrong.

I replied earlier - but, as so often, my message was not posted by 
the list. I think David Sumbler is misreading Gould. As I see it, the 
illustration he mentions on page 10 is intended just to show that the 
semibreve is slightly wider horizontally than a black notehead - the 
point Gould has just made in the text. Her actual examples (there is 
one at the bottom of page 36) seems to show the left-alignment that 
he criticises.

Brian Barker