Re: [Qemu-devel] [RFC] Disk integrity in QEMU

[Rik van Riel]

Jamie Lokier wrote:
> Rik van Riel wrote:
> > > When cache=on, read requests may not actually go to the disk.  If a 
> > > previous read request (by some application on the system) has read the 
> > > same data, then it becomes a simple memcpy().  Also, the host IO 
> > > scheduler may do read ahead which means that the data may be available 
> > >from that. 
> >
> > This can be as much of a data integrity problem as
> > asynchronous writes, if various qemu/kvm guests are
> > accessing the same disk image with a cluster filesystem
> > like GFS.
>
> If there are multiple qemu/kvm guests accessing the same disk image in
> a cluster, provided the host cluster filesystem uses a fully coherent
> protocol, ordinary cached reads should be fine.  (E.g. not NFS).

The problem is when the synchronization only happens in the guests,
which is a legitimate and common configuration.

Ie. the hosts just pass through the IO and the guests run a GFS
cluster.

Caching either reads or writes at the host level causes problems.

--
All rights reversed.