Re: [Qemu-devel] Plan for error handling in QMP

[Luiz Capitulino]

On Thu, 26 Jul 2012 13:22:15 -0500
address@hidden wrote:

> 
> Hi,
> 
> We had a violent^Wheated discussion on IRC about how to move forward
> with Luiz's proposed error series.  I think we reached consensus.  This
> note attempts to outline that.

This looks great to me, violent^W heated discussions can be so productive :)

> 
> Principles
> ----------
> 1. Errors should be free formed strings with a class code
> 
> 2. There should be a small number of class codes (10-15) added
>    strictly when there are specific users of a code.
> 
> 3. The class code should be expressed as an enum data type in the normal
>    QMP schema.  Other than this, errors should have no structure in the
>    schema.[*]
> 
> 4. We should drop all dictionary arguments in the current error
>    mechanisms beyond 'class' and 'desc'.
> 
> 5. The following errors are used by libvirt:
>    - CommandNotFound: QMP parsing
>    - DeviceNotActive/KVMMissingCap: ballooning
>    - DeviceNotFound: drive_del
>    - MigrationExpected: cont
> 
> 6. We need to make sure that these errors are preserved while other
>    errors should be consolidated.
>    - We need to state very clear for 1.2 which errors are going away.
> 
> 7. We need to make sure that anything we expose in 1.2 stays that way.
>    If we're dropping 'InvalidParameterType' as a class code, it should be
>    dropped in 1.2.  This could be achieved by making all existing codes
>    except for those in (5) report 'UnknownError' or something.[*]
> 
> [*] I took a little bit of license with these.  Hopefully it's not
> controversial.
> 
> Regards,
> 
> Anthony Liguori
>    
>