[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[Qsos-commits] qsos/sheet/wiki wiki.qsos xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.q...
|
From: |
Francois Le Droff |
|
Subject: |
[Qsos-commits] qsos/sheet/wiki wiki.qsos xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.q... |
|
Date: |
Tue, 07 Nov 2006 09:12:40 +0000 |
CVSROOT: /sources/qsos
Module name: qsos
Changes by: Francois Le Droff <francoisledroff> 06/11/07 09:12:40
Added files:
sheet/wiki : wiki.qsos
sheet/wiki/xwiki: xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
Removed files:
sheet/wiki : xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
Log message:
refactor folder to match qsos format
CVSWeb URLs:
http://cvs.savannah.gnu.org/viewcvs/qsos/sheet/wiki/wiki.qsos?cvsroot=qsos&rev=1.1
http://cvs.savannah.gnu.org/viewcvs/qsos/sheet/wiki/xwiki-0.9.840.qsos?cvsroot=qsos&r1=1.3&r2=0
http://cvs.savannah.gnu.org/viewcvs/qsos/sheet/wiki/xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.qsos?cvsroot=qsos&rev=1.1
Patches:
Index: wiki.qsos
===================================================================
RCS file: wiki.qsos
diff -N wiki.qsos
--- /dev/null 1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
+++ wiki.qsos 7 Nov 2006 09:12:40 -0000 1.1
@@ -0,0 +1,1564 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<document>
+ <header>
+ <authors> Francois Le Droff </authors>
+ <dates>
+ <creation/>
+ <validation/>
+ </dates>
+ <language>en</language>
+ <appname/>
+ <release/>
+ <licenseid/>
+ <licensedesc/>
+ <url/>
+ <desc/>
+ <demourl/>
+ <qsosformat>1.6</qsosformat>
+ <qsosappfamily>wiki</qsosappfamily>
+ <qsosspecificformat/>
+ </header>
+
+<section name="generic" title="Generic section">
+ <desc>Generic criteria from QSOS version 1.6</desc>
+ <element name="intrinsicdurability" title="Intrinsic durability">
+ <desc>Intrinsic durability</desc>
+ <element name="maturity" title="Maturity">
+ <desc>Maturity</desc>
+ <element name="age" title="Age">
+ <desc0>less than 3 months</desc0>
+ <desc1>if between 3 months and 3 years</desc1>
+ <desc2>after 3 years</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="stability" title="Stability">
+ <desc0>Unstable software with numerous releases or patches generating
side effects</desc0>
+ <desc1>Stabilized production release existing but old. Difficulties to
stabilize developpement releases</desc1>
+ <desc2>Stabilized software. Releases provide bug fixes corrections but
mainly new functionalities</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="historyknowproblems" title="History, know problems">
+ <desc0>Software knows several problems which can be prohibitive</desc0>
+ <desc1>No know major problem or crisis</desc1>
+ <desc2>History of good management of crisis situations</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="forkprobability" title="Fork probability, source of
Forking">
+ <desc0>Software is very likely to be forked in the future</desc0>
+ <desc1>Software comes from a fork but has very few chances of being
forked in the future</desc1>
+ <desc2>Software has very little chance of being forked. It does not
come from a fork either</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="adoption" title="Adoption">
+ <desc>Adoption by community and industry</desc>
+ <element name="popularity" title="Popularity (related to: general
public, niche, ...)">
+ <desc0>Very few users identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Detectable use on Internet</desc1>
+ <desc2>Numerous users, numerous references</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="references" title="References">
+ <desc0>None</desc0>
+ <desc1>Few refences, non critical usages</desc1>
+ <desc2>Often implemented for critical applications</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="contributingcommunity" title="Contributing Community">
+ <desc0>No community or without real activity (forum, mailing list,
...)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Existing community with a notable activity</desc1>
+ <desc2>Strong community: big activity on forums, numerous contributors
and advocates</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="books" title="books">
+ <desc0>No book about the software</desc0>
+ <desc1>Less than 5 books about the software are available</desc1>
+ <desc2>More than 5 books about software are available, in several
languages</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="developmentleadership" title="Development leadership">
+ <desc>Organisation and leadership of developments</desc>
+ <element name="leadingteam" title="Leading team">
+ <desc0>1 to 2 individuals involved, not clearly identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Between 2 and 5 independent people</desc1>
+ <desc2>More than 5 people</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="managementstyle" title="Management style">
+ <desc0>Complete dictatorship</desc0>
+ <desc1>Enlightened despotism</desc1>
+ <desc2>Council of architects with identified leader (e.g: KDE)</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activity" title="Activity">
+ <desc>Activity of the project and around the software</desc>
+ <element name="developersidentificationturnover" title="Developers,
identification, turnover">
+ <desc0>Less than 3 developers, not clearly identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Between 4 and 7 developers, or more unidentified developers
with important turnover</desc1>
+ <desc2>More than 7 developers, very stable team</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activityonbugs" title="Activity on bugs">
+ <desc0>Slow reactivity in forum or on mailing list, or nothing
regarding bug fixes in releases note</desc0>
+ <desc1>Detectable activity but without process clearly exposed, loing
reaction/resolution time</desc1>
+ <desc2>Strong reactivity based on roles and tasks assignment</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activityonfunctionalities" title="Activity on
functionalities">
+ <desc0>No or few new functionalities</desc0>
+ <desc1>Evolution of the product driven by the core team or by user's
request without any clearly explained process</desc1>
+ <desc2>Tool(s) to manage feature requests, strong interaction with
roadmap</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activityonreleases" title="Activity on releases">
+ <desc0>Very weak activity on both production and development
releases</desc0>
+ <desc1>Activity on production and developmenet releases. Frequent
minor releases (bug fixes)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Important activity with frequent minor releases (bugs fixes)
and planned major releases relating to the roadmap forcast</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="industrializedsolution" title="Industrialized solution">
+ <desc>Industrialization level of the project</desc>
+ <element name="independenceofdevelopments" title="Independence of
developments">
+ <desc0>Developments realized at 100% by employees of a single
company</desc0>
+ <desc1>60% maximum</desc1>
+ <desc2>20% maximum</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="services" title="Services">
+ <desc>Services offering</desc>
+ <element name="training" title="Training">
+ <desc0>No offer of training identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Offer exists but is restricted geographically and to one
language or is provided by a single contractor</desc1>
+ <desc2>Rich offers provided by several contractors, in serveral
languages and split into modules of gradual levels</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="support" title="Support">
+ <desc0>No offer of support except via public forums and mailing
lists</desc0>
+ <desc1>Offer exists but is provided by a single contractor without
strong commitment quality of services</desc1>
+ <desc2>Multiple service providers with strong commitment (e.g:
guaranteed resolution time)</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="consulting" title="Consulting">
+ <desc0>No offer of consulting service</desc0>
+ <desc1>Offer exists but is restricted geographically and to one
language or is provided by a single contractor</desc1>
+ <desc2>Consulting services provided by different contractors in
serveral languages</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="documentation" title="Documentation">
+ <desc0>No user documentation</desc0>
+ <desc1>Documentation exists but shifted in time, is restricted to one
language or is poorly detailed</desc1>
+ <desc2>Documentation always up to date, translated and possibly adapted
to different target readers (end user, sysadmin, manager, ...)</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="qualityassurance" title="Quality Assurance">
+ <desc>Quality assurance process</desc>
+ <element name="quality" title="Quality Assurance">
+ <desc0>No QA process</desc0>
+ <desc1>Identifies QA process but not much formalized and with no
tool</desc1>
+ <desc2>Automatic testing process included in code's life-cycle with
publication of results</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="tools" title="Tools">
+ <desc0>No bug or feature request management tool</desc0>
+ <desc1>Standard tools provided (for instance by a hosting forge) but
poorly used</desc1>
+ <desc2>Very active use of tools for roles/tasks allocation and
progress monitoring</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packaging" title="Packaging">
+ <desc>Packaging for various operating systems</desc>
+ <element name="packagingsource" title="Source">
+ <desc0>Software can't be installed from source without lot of
work</desc0>
+ <desc1>Installation from source is limited and depends on very strict
conditions (OS, arch, lib, ...)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Installation from source is easy</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingdebian" title="Debian">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for Debian</desc0>
+ <desc1>A Debian package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingfreebsd" title="FreeBSD">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for FreeBSD</desc0>
+ <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A official port exists in FreeBSD</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packaginghpux" title="HP-UX">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for HP-UX</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A stable package is provided for HP-UX</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingmacosx" title="MacOSX">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for MacOSX</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingmandriva" title="Mandriva">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for Mandriva</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingnet" title="NetBSD">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for NetBSD</desc0>
+ <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A official port exists in NetBSD</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingopen" title="OpenBSD">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for OpenBSD</desc0>
+ <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A official port exists in OpenBSD</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingredhat" title="RedHat">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for RedHat/Fedora</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingsolaris" title="Solaris">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for Solaris</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support (e.g: SunFreeware.com )</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is supported by Sun for Solaris</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingsuse" title="SuSE">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for SuSE</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it doesn't have
official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingwindows" title="Windows">
+ <desc0>The project can't be installed on Windows</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it is limited or has important issues or
just cover some specific Windows release (e.g: Windows2000 and
WindowsXP)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Windows is full supported and a package is provided</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="exploitability" title="Exploitability">
+ <desc>Exploitability level</desc>
+ <element name="easeofuseergonomics" title="Ease of use, ergonomics">
+ <desc0>Difficult to use, requires an in depth knowledge of the software
functionality</desc0>
+ <desc1>Austere and very technical ergonomics</desc1>
+ <desc2>GUI including help functions and elaborated ergonomics</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="administrationmonitoring" title="Administration /
Monitoring">
+ <desc0>No administrative or monitoring functionalities</desc0>
+ <desc1>Existing, functionalities but uncomplete and or need
improvement</desc1>
+ <desc2>Complete and easy-to-use administration and monitoring
functionalities. Possible integration with external tools (e.g: SNMP, syslog,
...)</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="technicaladaptability" title="Technical adaptability">
+ <desc>Technical adaptability</desc>
+ <element name="modularity" title="Modularity">
+ <desc0>Monolithic software</desc0>
+ <desc1>Presence of hight level modules allowing a first level of
software adaptation</desc1>
+ <desc2>Modular conception, allowing easy adaptation of the software by
selecting or creating modules</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="codemodification" title="Code modification">
+ <desc0>Everything by hand</desc0>
+ <desc1>Recompilation possible but complex without any tools or
documentation</desc1>
+ <desc2>Recompilation with tools (e.g: make, ANT, ...) and documentation
provided</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="codeextension" title="Code extention">
+ <desc0>Any modification requires code recompilation</desc0>
+ <desc1>Architecture designed for static extension but requires
recompilation</desc1>
+ <desc2>Principle of plugin, architecture designed for dynamic extension
without recompilation</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="strategy" title="Strategy">
+ <desc>Project's strategy</desc>
+ <element name="license" title="License">
+ <desc>License</desc>
+ <element name="permissiveness" title="Permissiveness (only if user wants
to become owner of code)">
+ <desc0>Very strict license, like GPL</desc0>
+ <desc1>Moderate permissive license located between both extremes (GPL
and BSD) dual-licensing depending on the type of user (person, company, ...) or
their activities</desc1>
+ <desc2>Very permissive like BSD or Apache licenses</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="protectionagainstproprietaryforks" title="Protection
against proprietary forks">
+ <desc0>Very permissive like BSD or Apache licenses</desc0>
+ <desc1>Moderate permissive license located between both extremes (GPL
and BSD), dual-licensing depending on the type of user (person, company, ...)
or their activies</desc1>
+ <desc2>Very strict license, like GPL</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="copyrightowners" title="Copyright owners">
+ <desc0>Rights held by a few individuals or entities, making it easier to
change the license</desc0>
+ <desc1>Rights held by numerous individuals owning the code in a
homogeneous way, making relicense very difficult</desc1>
+ <desc2>Rights held by a legal entity in whom the community trusts (e.g:
FSF or ASF)</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="modificationofsourcecode" title="Modification of source
code">
+ <desc0>No pratical way to propose code modification</desc0>
+ <desc1>Tools provided to access and modify code (like CVS or SVN) but
not really used to develop the software</desc1>
+ <desc2>The code modification process is well defined, exposed and
respected, based on roles assignment</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="roadmap" title="Roadmap">
+ <desc0>No published roadmap</desc0>
+ <desc1>Existing roadmap without planning</desc1>
+ <desc2>Versionned roadmap, with planning and measure of delays</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="sponsor" title="Sponsor">
+ <desc0>Software has no sponsor, the core team is not paid</desc0>
+ <desc1>Software has an unique sponsor who might determine its
strategy</desc1>
+ <desc2>Software is sponsored by industry</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="strategicalindependence" title="Strategical independence">
+ <desc0>No detectable strategy or strong dependency on one unique actor
(person, company, sponsor)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Strategical vision shared with several other free and open source
projects but without strong commitment from copyrights owners</desc1>
+ <desc2>Strong independence of the code team, legal entity holding
rights, strong involvement in the standardization process</desc2>
+ <score></score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+</section>
+
+
+<section name="webappprerequisite" title="web application prerequisites">
+
+ <element name="platform" title="platform on which the web application is
running">
+ <desc>Detail here the platform details and implementation language(s) and
its(their) version
+ </desc>
+ <element name="j2eeplatform" title="Is the web application running on a
j2ee platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section the J2EE or JavaEE specifications
used an their versions as well as the supported servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="phpplatform" title="Is the web application running on a php
platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section php versions and the supported
servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="cgiplatform" title="Is the web application running on a cgi
platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section cgi versions and the supported
servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mod_perlplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a mod_perl platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section cgi versions and the supported
servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+
+</section>
+
+<section name="websecurity" title="Security for web application">
+
+
+ <element name="authentifaction" title="Authentification Backend">
+ <element name="authenbackendldap" title="LDAP">
+ <desc0>No LDAP based authentification available</desc0>
+ <desc1>LDAP available but limited (e.g: group mapping limited,
etc)</desc1>
+ <desc2>LDAP is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="authenbackendad" title="Active Directory">
+ <desc0>No Active Directory based authentification
available</desc0>
+ <desc1>Active Directory available but limited (e.g: group
mapping limited, etc)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Active Directory is one of the recommended
authentification backend</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="authenbackenddb" title="data base">
+ <desc>Here we do not attach importance on supported data
bases, please see the
+ storage support section</desc>
+ <desc0>No data base base authentification availble</desc0>
+ <desc1>Data base available but limited (e.g: group mapping
limited, etc)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Data base is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="usersrightsmanagement" title="User Rights Management">
+ <element name="accessrights" title="access rights management">
+ <desc>
+ Does the system support access rights:
+ to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users on the overall system
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported, every user has the same
capabilities</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported, but not fine grained</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported, and the capabilities are exhaustive
according to the system capabilities.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="usersgroups" title="User group's management">
+ <desc>
+ Does the system support users group and thus, users group
access rights management:
+ to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users groups ?
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partially supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="spaceaccessrights" title="Space access rights
management">
+ <desc>
+ Is the web content dividable in subparts, spaces ?
+ Does the system support access rights for those spaces:
+ to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users
+ (and users group, if they are supported. ) on specific
space/sub-part of the system ?
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported, the system is not divided in
spaces</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partially supported, but not fine grained</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="antispammingandvandalism" title="anti spamming and
vandalism features">
+ <element name="hostblocking" title="Host Blocking">
+ <desc>
+ Host Blocking : Deny access from IP list
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="blacklist" title="Black List">
+ <desc>
+ Blacklist (of known URL ,word or content to associate with
spam)
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="captcha" title="CAPTCHA">
+ <desc>
+ CAPTCHA : to diffenciate a robot from an anonymous user
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="robotscontrol" title="robots and search engine control
features">
+ <desc>
+ robots and search engine control features, such as :
+ nofollow (external links tags with rel="nofollow");
+ Delayed Indexing (of search engine, to have time to track down
the spam and vandalism).
+ Do Detail in the comment section.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>No such features</desc0>
+ <desc1>Limited features</desc1>
+ <desc2>Such features are supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="signatureandcontentprotection" title="other signature and
content protection features">
+ <element name="signaturemechansim" title="Signing">
+ <desc>support for digital cypher (e.g: GNU PGP)</desc>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="digitalwatermarking" title="Digital watermarking">
+ <desc>
+ Digital watermarking is a technique which allows an individual
+ to add hidden copyright notices or other verification messages
+ to digital audio, video, or image signals and documents
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="DRM" title="DRM">
+ <desc/>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="mailencryption" title="Mail Encryption">
+ <desc/>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+</section>
+<section name="storagesupport" title="Storage support">
+
+ <element name="file system" title="file system storage">
+ <desc>
+ The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in (flat) files in
the file system.
+ Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product nor the
opposite,
+ it really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>The data persisted by the software cant be stored in
flatfiles</desc0>
+ <desc1>The data persisted by the software can be stored in flatfiles,
though it's not the default option.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The data persisted by the software is only stored in
flatfiles</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="database" title="Data Base">
+ <element name="rdbms" title="relational database support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
relational databases.
+ Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product
nor the opposite, it
+ really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
If the score is 1 or
+ 2, do detail (in the comment section) the supported db (MySQL,
PostgreSQL, Oracle,
+ SQLite, other) and their version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any relational
databases.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports a few relational databases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market
relational databases.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="xmldbms" title="xml database support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in XML
databases. Reminder:
+ here, a higher score does not mean a better product nor the
opposite, it really
+ depends on your needs and non functional requirements. If the
score is 1 or 2, do
+ detail (in the comment section) the supported db (BerkeleyDB ,
other) and their
+ version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any XML databases.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports a few XML databases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market XML
databases.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="odbms" title="object database support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
object (oriented)
+ databases. Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a
better product nor the
+ opposite, it really depends on your needs and non functional
requirements. If the
+ score is 1 or 2, do detail (in the comment section) the
supported db (ObjectDB,
+ Versant, Cache, other) and their version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any object databases.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports a few object databases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market object
databases.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="rcs" title="revision control system support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
revision control system.
+ Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product
nor the opposite, it
+ really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
If the score is 1 or
+ 2, do detail (in the comment section) the supported db (CVS,
SVN, ClearCase, other)
+ and their version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any rcs.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports just one or a few rcs.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market
rcs.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="datawarehouse" title="Data Warehouse">
+ <desc>Does the system support data warehousing?</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists with limitation (TODO)</desc1>
+ <desc2></desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+
+</section>
+
+<section name="webcompatibility" title="Web compatibility">
+
+ <element name="webstandards" title="Standards">
+ <element name="htmlstandard" title="HTML">
+ <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
+ <desc0>Page not valid (parse errors)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Page not valid with important errors (encoding mismatch)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Page valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute, use of
unknow attribute)</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="xhtmlstandard" title="XHTML">
+ <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
+ <desc0>Page not valid (parse errors)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Page not valid with important errors (encoding mismatch)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Page valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute, use of
unknow attribute)</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="cssstandard" title="CSS">
+ <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
+ <desc0>CSS doesn't or no valid not valide (parse errors)</desc0>
+ <desc1>CSS not valid with important errors (encoding mismatch)</desc1>
+ <desc2>CSS valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute, use of
unknow attribute)</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+
+ <element name="webbestpractice" title="Best Practive">
+
<desc>http://developer.apple.com/internet/webcontent/bestwebdev.htmls</desc>
+ <element name="tablepsitioning" title="Table Positioning">
+ <desc>html tables should not be used for layout/positioning, css is
there to help.</desc>
+ <desc2>html tables are not used for layout/positioning</desc2>
+ <desc1>not too much used</desc1>
+ <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="frameuse" title="Frame use">
+ <desc>Frame use </desc>
+ <desc2>frame are not used</desc2>
+ <desc1>frame are rarely used</desc1>
+ <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="iframeuse" title="iFrame use">
+ <desc>iFrame use </desc>
+ <desc2>iframe are not used</desc2>
+ <desc1>iframe are rarely used</desc1>
+ <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="cssdesignedforprintout" title="css designed for printout">
+ <desc>css designed for printout</desc>
+ <desc0>no</desc0>
+ <desc1>yes, but print-outs are not well rendered for a few use
cases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>yes</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="supportedbrowser" title="Supported Browser">
+ <desc>Supported Browser</desc>
+ <element name="browsermozillafirefox" title="Mozilla and Firefox">
+ <desc>Firefox, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browserkonqueror" title="Konqueror">
+ <desc>Konqueror, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browsermsie" title="MSIE">
+ <desc>MSIE, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browsersafari" title="Safari">
+ <desc>Safarie, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browserlegacy" title="legacy browsers">
+ <desc>Legacy browser are browser outdated like MSIE4 and Netscape 4,
please detail the
+ supported version in the comment section.</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+
+ <element name="browserrequiredenablings" title="Best Practive">
+ <desc>Browser required enablings: javascript, applet, SVG, and flash.
Reminder: here, a higher
+ score does not mean a better product nor the opposite, it really depends
on your needs and non
+ functional requirements. </desc>
+ <element name="javascriptrequired" title="Javascript required">
+ <desc> Is the browser javascript enabling required ? If the score is 1
or 2, do indicate in
+ the comment section the required jvm version. If the score is 1, do
detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface makes no use of javascript, and thus, does not need
javascript to run at
+ full flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of javascript but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>Javascript is necessary to use the interface (beacuse it's AJAX
based for instance).</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="jvmrequired" title="a Java plugin is required">
+ <desc>Does the browser needs a java plugin (to enable applet) ? If the
score is 1 or 2, do
+ indicate in the comment section the required jvm version. If the score
is 1, do detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface does not contains any applet, and thus, does not
need java to run at full
+ flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of applet(s) but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A Java plugin is necessary to use the interface, the applets are
key players in it.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="svgrequired" title="a SVG plugin is required">
+ <desc> Does the browser needs a SVG plugin ? If score is 1 or 2, do
indicate in the comment
+ section the required SVG version. If the score is 1, do detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface does not contains any SVG graph, and thus, does not
need any SVG plugin
+ to run at full flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of SVG but can properly function without
it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A SVG plugin is necessary to use the interface, the SVG graph are
part of key features
+ of the interface.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="flashrequired" title="a flash plugin is required">
+ <desc>Does the browser needs a flash plugin ? If score is 1 or 2, do
indicate in the comment
+ section the required flash version. If the score is 1, do detail.
</desc>
+ <desc0>The interface does not contains any flash graph, and thus, does
not need any flash
+ plugin to run at full flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of flash but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A flash plugin is necessary to use the interface, the interface
is mainly made of
+ flash.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+</section>
+<section name="UI" title="User interface">
+
+ <element name="i18nUI" title="internationalisation support">
+ <desc>
+ Is the whole user interface internationalizable ? Is Unicode Supported
?
+ Are Right-to-Left languages supported (as for Hebrew and Arabic) ?
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>Limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="skinableUI" title="internationalisation support">
+ <desc>
+ Does the UI have a complete skin system ?
+ (a User/UserGroup customizable interface for instance)
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>Limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+</section>
+<section name="webcontentmanagement" title="Web content management support">
+ <desc>This section describes the system's web content/attachement
management features.</desc>
+
+
+ <element name="metadata" title="Support for Meta data on content">
+ <desc>Meta data are information related to a document like (keywords,
category, author, copyright holder, ...)</desc>
+ <element name="keyword" title="Keyword support">
+ <desc>Metadata are all the specific keywords that can be attached
to a document (e.g:
+ sun, holydays, summer for a picture from your last
holydays)</desc>
+ <desc0>Can't add specific key word</desc0>
+ <desc1>Key word can be add but with limitation: limited list, no
easy to way extend the
+ list</desc1>
+ <desc2>Key word power are easy to add extend</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="hierarchicalclassification" title="Hierarchical
Classification">
+ <desc>Ability to do a classication in predesigned hierarchy,
category or namespaces</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exist but is limited.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A new document can quickly be registered in the
hierarchy</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="documentsupport" title="document types support">
+ <desc> Supported means that the internal engine is able to store and
eventually read or
+ parse file content in order to create preview file, find key words,
and thus use for
+ search, merge and diff</desc>
+ <element name="textcontent" title="text formats">
+ <element name="txt" title="text files">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview nor search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformathtml" title="HTML files">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview nor search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformatrtf" title="RTF (Rich Text Format)">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformatcsv" title="CSV">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformatxml" title="XML files">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="opendocumentsupport" title="Opendocument (open office)
files support">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are supported
but parsing is not
+ (and consequently nor preview or search, diff, merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="msofficesupport" title="MS Office files support">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are supported
but parsing is not
+ (and consequently nor preview or search, diff, merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="vectorialformat" title="common vectorial format">
+ <desc>Format are: wmf, svg</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partialy (buggy or limited feature)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ </element>
+
+
+
+ <element name="versioncontrol" title="On line version control">
+ <desc> The documents targeted by the version control are those listed
as fully supported in the above "documentsupport" elements </desc>
+ <element name="history"
+ title="online access to each pages/docs (of fully supported media)
history/versioning">
+ <desc0>No history/versioning</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited number of document revisions</desc1>
+ <desc2>unlimited number of document revisions</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="diff"
+ title="online supports for version differencing diff and
retrieving prior versions.">
+ <desc0>No diff feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>Revision Diffs with the latest</desc1>
+ <desc2>Revision Diffs with the all</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="rollback"
+ title="online supports for retrieving/rollbacking to prior
versions.">
+ <desc0>No rollback feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>rollback to the latest</desc1>
+ <desc2>rollback to all</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mergetools"
+ title="tools to facilitate merge pages/docs (of fully supported
media).">
+ <desc0>No such merging tools</desc0>
+ <desc1>basic merge tools</desc1>
+ <desc2>smart merge tools</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="picture" title="picture formats support">
+ <desc>Supported means that the internal engine is able to store and
eventually make thumbnail/preview file</desc>
+ <element name="commonpictureformat" title="common file format">
+ <desc>Format are: jpg, gif, png, bmp, tiff, xpm, </desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="commercialpictureformat" title="commercial formats">
+ <desc>Format are: psp (PaintShopPro), psd (Photopshop)</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="search" title="Support for search">
+ <desc>The metadata and media content support is to be detailed in the
above metadata and mediasupport elements </desc>
+ <element name="searchengine" title="Search Engine feature">
+ <desc0>No search engine available</desc0>
+ <desc1>Searches are limited (to filename, metadata or text content
for instance)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Searches are feasable through most of the media content and
the metadata</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="searchAPI"
+ title="Search API for more detailed searching in the contents and
their meta-data">
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exist but is limited.</desc1>
+ <desc2>This feature is fully powered</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="updatenotification" title="Support for new content or
update notifications">
+ <element name="recentchanges" title="recent changes advertised on the
web interface">
+ <desc0>No such features</desc0>
+ <desc1>recent changes advertised according to the today's
date</desc1>
+ <desc2>recent changes advertised only changes that happened since
user's last visit</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="rss" title="support for rss feed">
+ <desc>Do detail the rss feed format/protocol in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>This feature exists and feeds are tunable and/or atom feeds
are available</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="othernotifications" title="support for other
notifications media">
+ <desc>Do detail the media in the comment section</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists for one communication media</desc1>
+ <desc2>This feature exists for several media: e.mail, and IM for
instance </desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="contentworkflow" title="Content management Workflow">
+ <element name="simpleLock" title="Simple Lock mechanism">
+ <desc>Ability to lock file avoid data lost or synchronization
issues</desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature just exists</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists, and administrator can quickly unlock a
file from an user. A time out system exists to unlock file after a certain
amount of time.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="workflow" title="Content management workflow">
+ <desc>Adding or updating a document in the system may be done
through a complex
+ workflow. Do detail in the comment section</desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature just exists, but the workflow is simple, a
single moderator system
+ for instance</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists, and the workflow is tunable.</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="pluginsandpluginability"
+ title="Plugins, pluginability, built-in objects, and page templates">
+
+ <element name="pluginability" title="plugin ability">
+ <desc>adequate software architecture for custom plugin creation,
easy plugin interface
+ for writing your own additions. Do detail in the comment section
the supported plugin languages </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="remoteAPI" title="XML/RPC Remote API">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>poor API</desc1>
+ <desc2>rich API</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="webserviceplugin" title="web service plugin">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited integration capabilities</desc1>
+ <desc2>good capabilities</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="feedagregation" title="ability to agregate feeds">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited integration capabilities</desc1>
+ <desc2>good capabilities</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="builtinobjects" title="builtin objects or plugins">
+ <element name="calendars" title="Calendars and Calendars events">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="blogs" title="blogs">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>A single blog is possible</desc1>
+ <desc2>multiple blogs supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="polls" title="polls and vote editing and
publishing">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="photoalbums" title="photo albums editing and
publishing">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="slideshows"
+ title="slide show editing and launching within the internet
browser">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="bugtrackingintegration"
+ title="Bug tracking system integration (tickets linking and
meta data extraction)">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited integration: tickets linking </desc1>
+ <desc2>well supported: tickets linking and meta data
extraction</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="otherplugins" title="other noticeable built-in
plugins">
+ <desc> others: FAQ, meeting minutes, Action Tracker plugin,
bookmarklet,
+ Geolocalisation features: GeoURL or googleMaps plugins,
Tagging and Tag clouds
+ (delicio.us, technorati, others), etc. Do list the plugins in
the comment section. </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>a few other plugins </desc1>
+ <desc2>many other plugins</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+
+
+
+</section>
+
+
+
+
+ <section name="wikipagelinks"
+ title="wiki page creating, naming, linking, listing and statistics">
+
+ <element name="pagenaming" title="page creation/naming and linking">
+ <desc> the wiki pages (or documents) can be viewed, created or
edited at anytime by
+ anyone from a web browser (with certain limitations for
protected areas cf. the
+ websecurity section ). </desc>
+ <desc0>The wiki page are only created and accessible through
CamelCase links</desc0>
+ <desc1>the wiki supports free links</desc1>
+ <desc2>the wiki supports free links and image links</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="discussion" title="Each pages has a
comments/discussions area">
+ <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>supported : access to a discussion/comment area particular
to that page</desc1>
+ <desc2>fine grained discussion supported : possible to comment the
page by section</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="pagelists" title="wiki pages administration and
navigation lists">
+ <element name="availablepageslisting" title="list of all available
pages">
+ <desc> list of all the existing pages (and pages within the
hierarchy, if the
+ hierarchy is supported, cf. webcontentmanagement section)
</desc>
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="backlinks"
+ title="Backlinks: list of all the pages linking back to the
current one">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="undefinedpages"
+ title="Undefined Pages : pages that are referred to, but not
yet created">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="orphanedpages"
+ title="Orphaned Pages : not currently referred to by any other
page, thus meaning they are inaccessible through any other means">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="lockedpages"
+ title="Lock pages: currently hold for editing pages, if the
Lock is supported, cf. webcontentmanagement section">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="wantedpages"
+ title="Wanted Pages: list of all the pages wanted for creation
by the users">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mostleastpopularpages" title="Most/Least Popular
pages">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="recentlyvisitedpages" title="Recently visited
pages">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ </section>
+
+
+
+ <section name="pageediting" title="page editing features">
+
+ <element name="onlinepageediting" title="online page editing">
+ <desc> All the pages (or documents) can edited at anytime by
anyone from a web browser,
+ (with certain limitations for protected areas cf. the
websecurity section ). The
+ following element details the editing features. </desc>
+ <desc0>Not supported, it's not a wiki</desc0>
+ <desc1>n.a. </desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="i18nofdocuments"
+ title="i18n of documents : Internationalization and Multilingual
capability for documents">
+ <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support: unicode, nor Right-to-Left Support (as for
Hebrew and Arabic)
+ are supported </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully implemented</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="wikisyntax" title="wiki syntax or wikitext features">
+ <desc> The following features list is supposed to show the ease of
learning and using:
+ writing, reading and modifying wiki pages </desc>
+ <comment/>
+ <element name="lightweightmarkuplanguage" title="light weight
markup language support">
+ <desc> the most known light weight markup language are : CREOLE
+ (http://www.wikicreole.org/wiki/Home), BBCode
+ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode), Textile
+
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textile_%28markup_language%29), Markdown
+ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown), BBCode
+ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode), Radeox API
+ (http://radeox.org/space/start) </desc>
+ <desc0>this wiki has a very specific or very poor
syntax</desc0>
+ <desc1>this wiki has a uncommon or poor syntax </desc1>
+ <desc2>this wiki support a standard and rich light weight
markup language</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="tableedition"
+ title="Tables edition ease: simple and complex (colspan and
rowspan) table support">
+ <desc0>not implemented</desc0>
+ <desc1>implemented but with a limited API, simple tables
only</desc1>
+ <desc2>implemented exhaustively, simple and complex (colspan
and rowspan) table
+ support</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="htmltags" title="HTML Tags allowed">
+ <desc0>not allowed</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="toc" title="TOC (Table of content) Auto-generation">
+ <desc0>not implemented</desc0>
+ <desc1>implemented but with a poor API</desc1>
+ <desc2>implemented exhaustively</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="wikicomments" title="Internal Comments / comments
in the wiki page code">
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>n.a.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="otherspecialsyntax" title="other specialized wiki
syntax">
+ <desc> support for footnotes, quote, interwiki links, emoticon
and other icon rendering
+ through syntax. Do list in the comment section. </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>a few other syntax/editing plugin </desc1>
+ <desc2>many others</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="pageeditingusability" title="page editing Usability">
+ <desc> Does the wiki provides the following features: Preview
before saving; Section
+ Editing or whole page only editing; Double-Click on the text
to Edit; access Keys
+ (to save, edit, quit ...) ; different editor are supported
(some with editing
+ Toolbar); a fully WYSIWYG editor is available. Do detail the
available features in
+ the comment section. </desc>
+ <desc0>very limited features</desc0>
+ <desc1>a few of those features are available</desc1>
+ <desc2>all those features are available</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+
+
+
+ <element name="spellchecker" title="spell checker">
+ <desc>Useless feature if you use a decent browser like firefox2
that contains an inline spell checking:
+ a built-in spell checker enables users to quickly check the
spelling of text entered into Web forms
+ (like this one) without having to use a seperate application.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>no spell checker availble or it's just based on a too
limited dictionary that make it
+ being a wast of time</desc0>
+ <desc1>working dictionnary but limited (e.g: grammar not included,
false positive, hard to
+ extend)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Powerful dictionary</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="contentincludes"
+ title="Content Includes : Inclusion of pages inside another wiki
page">
+ <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+
+ <element name="flagging"
+ title="editing flags features : meta data added by the commiters
when editing">
+ <desc> Those features are not that usefull when the
pagesversioncontrol is well
+ designed, they can be things like: "Minor Changes flagging"
feature, or "Change
+ Summary" features </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited features</desc1>
+ <desc2>exhaustive features</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+
+
+
+
+ <element name="advancededitingfeatures" title="Advanced editing
features">
+
+ <element name="templating" title="MetaData Form and templating
ability">
+ <desc> Design Engine for Meta-Data and Forms, allowing to
design custom forms with
+ text fields, textarea fields, number fields, static select
fields API to display
+ meta-data in view and edit mode inside the Wiki page. (to
create custom forms
+ and templates and In-place (inline) editing of form
information in pages). </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited features</desc1>
+ <desc2>exhaustive features with a rich API</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="codesyntaxhighlighting" title="Code Syntax
Highlighting">
+ <desc> hightlight (colorize) source code snippets when added
to a wikipage </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>present but minimal</desc1>
+ <desc2>very well supported: colorize according to
code/language specifications</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mathformulas" title="support for Math formulas
edition and display">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported and standard : LaTeX syntac support: to
edit mathematical
+ formulas in Latex syntax directly in the Wiki and display
them as images</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="tableplugins" title="plugins associated with wiki
table syntax">
+ <element name="tablesorting" title="Table sorting plugin">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="spreadsheet"
+ title="Add spreadsheet formulae like $SUM($ABOVE()) to
tables">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="chartplugin" title="ChartPlugin : charts
creation from wiki tables">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="media" title="media editing features">
+ <desc> support for Image Editing (applet for instance) or
other media in-line editor
+ (SVG, MindMap ...) </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>one or two editing capabilities like these </desc1>
+ <desc2>many capabilities</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+
+ <element name="wikiscripting"
+ title="scripting/programming ability within the wiki page code">
+ <desc> programming API to create custom dynamic web applications
only using the Wiki
+ interface. Do detail in the comment section the supported wiki
scripting languages. </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited API </desc1>
+ <desc2>rich API</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+
+
+
+ </section>
+
+
+
+
+
+ <section name="pagesexport" title="wiki pages exports">
+ <desc> RSS feeds are already described in the webcontentmanagement
include/section. Here we list the other export kinds. </desc>
+ <element name="rawexport" title="raw export: wiki page as coded">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="htmlexport" title="page HTML Export (without the wiki
navigation element)">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="xmlexport" title="page XML export">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="pdfexport" title="page PDF export">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ <element name="customoutput" title="custom output plugin-ability (RSS,
FOAF)">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment/>
+ <score/>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+
+
+
+
+
+
+</document>
Index: xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
===================================================================
RCS file: xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
diff -N xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
--- /dev/null 1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
+++ xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.qsos 7 Nov 2006 09:12:40 -0000 1.1
@@ -0,0 +1,1435 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<document>
+ <header>
+ <authors> Francois Le Droff </authors>
+ <dates>
+ <creation></creation>
+ <validation></validation>
+ </dates>
+ <language>en</language>
+ <appname>xwiki</appname>
+ <release>0.9.840</release>
+ <licenseid>32</licenseid>
+ <licensedesc>GNU LGPL</licensedesc>
+ <url>http://www.xwiki.org</url>
+ <desc></desc>
+ <demourl>http://www.xwiki.org</demourl>
+ <qsosformat>1.6</qsosformat>
+ <qsosappfamily>wiki</qsosappfamily>
+ <qsosspecificformat></qsosspecificformat>
+ </header>
+ <section name="generic" title="Generic section">
+ <desc>Generic criteria from QSOS version 1.6</desc>
+ <element name="intrinsicdurability" title="Intrinsic durability">
+ <desc>Intrinsic durability</desc>
+ <element name="maturity" title="Maturity">
+ <desc>Maturity</desc>
+ <element name="age" title="Age">
+ <desc0>less than 3 months</desc0>
+ <desc1>if between 3 months and 3 years</desc1>
+ <desc2>after 3 years</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="stability" title="Stability">
+ <desc0>Unstable software with numerous releases or patches
generating side effects</desc0>
+ <desc1>Stabilized production release existing but old.
Difficulties to stabilize developpement releases</desc1>
+ <desc2>Stabilized software. Releases provide bug fixes
corrections but mainly new functionalities</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="historyknowproblems" title="History, know problems">
+ <desc0>Software knows several problems which can be
prohibitive</desc0>
+ <desc1>No know major problem or crisis</desc1>
+ <desc2>History of good management of crisis situations</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="forkprobability" title="Fork probability, source of
Forking">
+ <desc0>Software is very likely to be forked in the
future</desc0>
+ <desc1>Software comes from a fork but has very few chances of
being forked in the future</desc1>
+ <desc2>Software has very little chance of being forked. It does
not come from a fork either</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="adoption" title="Adoption">
+ <desc>Adoption by community and industry</desc>
+ <element name="popularity" title="Popularity (related to: general
public, niche, ...)">
+ <desc0>Very few users identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Detectable use on Internet</desc1>
+ <desc2>Numerous users, numerous references</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="references" title="References">
+ <desc0>None</desc0>
+ <desc1>Few refences, non critical usages</desc1>
+ <desc2>Often implemented for critical applications</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="contributingcommunity" title="Contributing
Community">
+ <desc0>No community or without real activity (forum, mailing
list, ...)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Existing community with a notable activity</desc1>
+ <desc2>Strong community: big activity on forums, numerous
contributors and advocates</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="books" title="books">
+ <desc0>No book about the software</desc0>
+ <desc1>Less than 5 books about the software are
available</desc1>
+ <desc2>More than 5 books about software are available, in
several languages</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="developmentleadership" title="Development leadership">
+ <desc>Organisation and leadership of developments</desc>
+ <element name="leadingteam" title="Leading team">
+ <desc0>1 to 2 individuals involved, not clearly
identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Between 2 and 5 independent people</desc1>
+ <desc2>More than 5 people</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment>5 admins</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="managementstyle" title="Management style">
+ <desc0>Complete dictatorship</desc0>
+ <desc1>Enlightened despotism</desc1>
+ <desc2>Council of architects with identified leader (e.g:
KDE)</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment>Out of 5 Admins, Ludovic Dubost, Jeremi Joslin and
Vincent Massol are the main drivers.</comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activity" title="Activity">
+ <desc>Activity of the project and around the software</desc>
+ <element name="developersidentificationturnover"
title="Developers, identification, turnover">
+ <desc0>Less than 3 developers, not clearly identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Between 4 and 7 developers, or more unidentified
developers with important turnover</desc1>
+ <desc2>More than 7 developers, very stable team</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment>56 developpers</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activityonbugs" title="Activity on bugs">
+ <desc0>Slow reactivity in forum or on mailing list, or nothing
regarding bug fixes in releases note</desc0>
+ <desc1>Detectable activity but without process clearly exposed,
loing reaction/resolution time</desc1>
+ <desc2>Strong reactivity based on roles and tasks
assignment</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment>the process is clearly exposed (mainly through jira),
the resolution are not always fast</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activityonfunctionalities" title="Activity on
functionalities">
+ <desc0>No or few new functionalities</desc0>
+ <desc1>Evolution of the product driven by the core team or by
user's request without any clearly explained process</desc1>
+ <desc2>Tool(s) to manage feature requests, strong interaction
with roadmap</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="activityonreleases" title="Activity on releases">
+ <desc0>Very weak activity on both production and development
releases</desc0>
+ <desc1>Activity on production and developmenet releases.
Frequent minor releases (bug fixes)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Important activity with frequent minor releases (bugs
fixes) and planned major releases relating to the roadmap forcast</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="industrializedsolution" title="Industrialized solution">
+ <desc>Industrialization level of the project</desc>
+ <element name="independenceofdevelopments" title="Independence of
developments">
+ <desc0>Developments realized at 100% by employees of a single
company</desc0>
+ <desc1>60% maximum</desc1>
+ <desc2>20% maximum</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment>The core developpers are in Ludovic Dubost team, He is
the founder of Xpernet, the xwiki editor.</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="services" title="Services">
+ <desc>Services offering</desc>
+ <element name="training" title="Training">
+ <desc0>No offer of training identified</desc0>
+ <desc1>Offer exists but is restricted geographically and to one
language or is provided by a single contractor</desc1>
+ <desc2>Rich offers provided by several contractors, in serveral
languages and split into modules of gradual levels</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+
<comment>http://www.xwiki.com/xwiki/bin/view/Company/Training+Services</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="support" title="Support">
+ <desc0>No offer of support except via public forums and mailing
lists</desc0>
+ <desc1>Offer exists but is provided by a single contractor
without strong commitment quality of services</desc1>
+ <desc2>Multiple service providers with strong commitment (e.g:
guaranteed resolution time)</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+
<comment>http://www.xwiki.com/xwiki/bin/view/Company/Support+Contracts
+</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="consulting" title="Consulting">
+ <desc0>No offer of consulting service</desc0>
+ <desc1>Offer exists but is restricted geographically and to one
language or is provided by a single contractor</desc1>
+ <desc2>Consulting services provided by different contractors in
serveral languages</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+
<comment>http://www.xwiki.com/xwiki/bin/view/Company/Development+and+Consulting</comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="documentation" title="Documentation">
+ <desc0>No user documentation</desc0>
+ <desc1>Documentation exists but shifted in time, is restricted to
one language or is poorly detailed</desc1>
+ <desc2>Documentation always up to date, translated and possibly
adapted to different target readers (end user, sysadmin, manager, ...)</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="qualityassurance" title="Quality Assurance">
+ <desc>Quality assurance process</desc>
+ <element name="quality" title="Quality Assurance">
+ <desc0>No QA process</desc0>
+ <desc1>Identifies QA process but not much formalized and with
no tool</desc1>
+ <desc2>Automatic testing process included in code's life-cycle
with publication of results</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="tools" title="Tools">
+ <desc0>No bug or feature request management tool</desc0>
+ <desc1>Standard tools provided (for instance by a hosting
forge) but poorly used</desc1>
+ <desc2>Very active use of tools for roles/tasks allocation and
progress monitoring</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment>svn, maven, ant, forge objectweb, jira.org,
xwiki.org</comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packaging" title="Packaging">
+ <desc>Packaging for various operating systems</desc>
+ <element name="packagingsource" title="Source">
+ <desc0>Software can't be installed from source without lot of
work</desc0>
+ <desc1>Installation from source is limited and depends on very
strict conditions (OS, arch, lib, ...)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Installation from source is easy</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingdebian" title="Debian">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for Debian</desc0>
+ <desc1>A Debian package exists but it has important issues or
it doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingfreebsd" title="FreeBSD">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for FreeBSD</desc0>
+ <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't
have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A official port exists in FreeBSD</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packaginghpux" title="HP-UX">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for HP-UX</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A stable package is provided for HP-UX</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingmacosx" title="MacOSX">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for MacOSX</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingmandriva" title="Mandriva">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for Mandriva</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingnet" title="NetBSD">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for NetBSD</desc0>
+ <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't
have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A official port exists in NetBSD</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingopen" title="OpenBSD">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for OpenBSD</desc0>
+ <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't
have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>A official port exists in OpenBSD</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingredhat" title="RedHat">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for RedHat/Fedora</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingsolaris" title="Solaris">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for Solaris</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support (e.g: SunFreeware.com )</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is supported by Sun for Solaris</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingsuse" title="SuSE">
+ <desc0>The software is not packaged for SuSE</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="packagingwindows" title="Windows">
+ <desc0>The project can't be installed on Windows</desc0>
+ <desc1>A package exists but it is limited or has important
issues or just cover some specific Windows release (e.g: Windows2000 and
WindowsXP)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Windows is full supported and a package is
provided</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment>There's a zip with mysql tomcat and xwiki bundled
together.</comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="exploitability" title="Exploitability">
+ <desc>Exploitability level</desc>
+ <element name="easeofuseergonomics" title="Ease of use, ergonomics">
+ <desc0>Difficult to use, requires an in depth knowledge of the
software functionality</desc0>
+ <desc1>Austere and very technical ergonomics</desc1>
+ <desc2>GUI including help functions and elaborated
ergonomics</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="administrationmonitoring" title="Administration /
Monitoring">
+ <desc0>No administrative or monitoring functionalities</desc0>
+ <desc1>Existing, functionalities but uncomplete and or need
improvement</desc1>
+ <desc2>Complete and easy-to-use administration and monitoring
functionalities. Possible integration with external tools (e.g: SNMP, syslog,
...)</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="technicaladaptability" title="Technical adaptability">
+ <desc>Technical adaptability</desc>
+ <element name="modularity" title="Modularity">
+ <desc0>Monolithic software</desc0>
+ <desc1>Presence of hight level modules allowing a first level of
software adaptation</desc1>
+ <desc2>Modular conception, allowing easy adaptation of the
software by selecting or creating modules</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="codemodification" title="Code modification">
+ <desc0>Everything by hand</desc0>
+ <desc1>Recompilation possible but complex without any tools or
documentation</desc1>
+ <desc2>Recompilation with tools (e.g: make, ANT, ...) and
documentation provided</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="codeextension" title="Code extention">
+ <desc0>Any modification requires code recompilation</desc0>
+ <desc1>Architecture designed for static extension but requires
recompilation</desc1>
+ <desc2>Principle of plugin, architecture designed for dynamic
extension without recompilation</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="strategy" title="Strategy">
+ <desc>Project's strategy</desc>
+ <element name="license" title="License">
+ <desc>License</desc>
+ <element name="permissiveness" title="Permissiveness (only if user
wants to become owner of code)">
+ <desc0>Very strict license, like GPL</desc0>
+ <desc1>Moderate permissive license located between both
extremes (GPL and BSD) dual-licensing depending on the type of user (person,
company, ...) or their activities</desc1>
+ <desc2>Very permissive like BSD or Apache licenses</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="protectionagainstproprietaryforks"
title="Protection against proprietary forks">
+ <desc0>Very permissive like BSD or Apache licenses</desc0>
+ <desc1>Moderate permissive license located between both
extremes (GPL and BSD), dual-licensing depending on the type of user (person,
company, ...) or their activies</desc1>
+ <desc2>Very strict license, like GPL</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="copyrightowners" title="Copyright owners">
+ <desc0>Rights held by a few individuals or entities, making it
easier to change the license</desc0>
+ <desc1>Rights held by numerous individuals owning the code in a
homogeneous way, making relicense very difficult</desc1>
+ <desc2>Rights held by a legal entity in whom the community trusts
(e.g: FSF or ASF)</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment>Copyright 2006, XpertNet SARL, and individual
contributors as indicated by the contributors.txt.</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="modificationofsourcecode" title="Modification of
source code">
+ <desc0>No pratical way to propose code modification</desc0>
+ <desc1>Tools provided to access and modify code (like CVS or SVN)
but not really used to develop the software</desc1>
+ <desc2>The code modification process is well defined, exposed and
respected, based on roles assignment</desc2>
+ <score>2</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="roadmap" title="Roadmap">
+ <desc0>No published roadmap</desc0>
+ <desc1>Existing roadmap without planning</desc1>
+ <desc2>Versionned roadmap, with planning and measure of
delays</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment>http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Dev/Roadmap and on
Jira
+</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="sponsor" title="Sponsor">
+ <desc0>Software has no sponsor, the core team is not paid</desc0>
+ <desc1>Software has an unique sponsor who might determine its
strategy</desc1>
+ <desc2>Software is sponsored by industry</desc2>
+ <score>1</score>
+ <comment>The unique sponsor is xpernet, but the project is part of
ObjectWeb</comment>
+ </element>
+ <element name="strategicalindependence" title="Strategical
independence">
+ <desc0>No detectable strategy or strong dependency on one unique
actor (person, company, sponsor)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Strategical vision shared with several other free and open
source projects but without strong commitment from copyrights owners</desc1>
+ <desc2>Strong independence of the code team, legal entity holding
rights, strong involvement in the standardization process</desc2>
+ <score>0</score>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="webappprerequisite" title="web application prerequisites">
+ <element name="platform" title="platform on which the web application is
running">
+ <desc>Detail here the platform details and implementation language(s)
and its(their) version
+ </desc>
+ <element name="j2eeplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a j2ee platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section the J2EE or JavaEE
specifications used an their versions as well as the supported servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment>all servlet containers should be able to run it.
+It's based on many standard os java library like hibernate,
velocity....</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="phpplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a php platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section php versions and the supported
servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="cgiplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a cgi platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section cgi versions and the supported
servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mod_perlplatform" title="Is the web application
running on a mod_perl platform?">
+ <desc>Detail in the comment section cgi versions and the supported
servers.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
+ <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
+ <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <comment></comment>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="websecurity" title="Security for web application">
+ <element name="authentifaction" title="Authentification Backend">
+ <element name="authenbackendldap" title="LDAP">
+ <desc0>No LDAP based authentification available</desc0>
+ <desc1>LDAP available but limited (e.g: group mapping limited,
etc)</desc1>
+ <desc2>LDAP is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="authenbackendad" title="Active Directory">
+ <desc0>No Active Directory based authentification available</desc0>
+ <desc1>Active Directory available but limited (e.g: group mapping
limited, etc)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Active Directory is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="authenbackenddb" title="data base">
+ <desc>Here we do not attach importance on supported data bases,
please see the
+ storage support section</desc>
+ <desc0>No data base base authentification availble</desc0>
+ <desc1>Data base available but limited (e.g: group mapping
limited, etc)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Data base is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="usersrightsmanagement" title="User Rights Management">
+ <element name="accessrights" title="access rights management">
+ <desc>
+ Does the system support access rights:
+ to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users on the overall system
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported, every user has the same
capabilities</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported, but not fine grained</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported, and the capabilities are exhaustive
according to the system capabilities.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="usersgroups" title="User group's management">
+ <desc>
+ Does the system support users group and thus, users group
access rights management:
+ to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users groups ?
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partially supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="spaceaccessrights" title="Space access rights
management">
+ <desc>
+ Is the web content dividable in subparts, spaces ?
+ Does the system support access rights for those spaces:
+ to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users
+ (and users group, if they are supported. ) on specific
space/sub-part of the system ?
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported, the system is not divided in
spaces</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partially supported, but not fine grained</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="antispammingandvandalism" title="anti spamming and
vandalism features">
+ <element name="hostblocking" title="Host Blocking">
+ <desc>
+ Host Blocking : Deny access from IP list
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="blacklist" title="Black List">
+ <desc>
+ Blacklist (of known URL ,word or content to associate with
spam)
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="captcha" title="CAPTCHA">
+ <desc>
+ CAPTCHA : to diffenciate a robot from an anonymous user
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
+ <comment>captcha is available through a plugin</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="robotscontrol" title="robots and search engine control
features">
+ <desc>
+ robots and search engine control features, such as :
+ nofollow (external links tags with rel="nofollow");
+ Delayed Indexing (of search engine, to have time to track down
the spam and vandalism).
+ Do Detail in the comment section.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>No such features</desc0>
+ <desc1>Limited features</desc1>
+ <desc2>Such features are supported</desc2>
+ <comment>easily do-able</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="signatureandcontentprotection" title="other signature and
content protection features">
+ <element name="signaturemechansim" title="Signing">
+ <desc>support for digital cypher (e.g: GNU PGP)</desc>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="digitalwatermarking" title="Digital watermarking">
+ <desc>
+ Digital watermarking is a technique which allows an individual
+ to add hidden copyright notices or other verification messages
+ to digital audio, video, or image signals and documents
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="DRM" title="DRM">
+ <desc></desc>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mailencryption" title="Mail Encryption">
+ <desc></desc>
+ <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="storagesupport" title="Storage support">
+ <element name="file system" title="file system storage">
+ <desc>
+ The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in (flat) files in
the file system.
+ Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product nor the
opposite,
+ it really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>The data persisted by the software cant be stored in
flatfiles</desc0>
+ <desc1>The data persisted by the software can be stored in flatfiles,
though it's not the default option.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The data persisted by the software is only stored in
flatfiles</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="database" title="Data Base">
+ <element name="rdbms" title="relational database support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
relational databases.
+ Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product
nor the opposite, it
+ really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
If the score is 1 or
+ 2, do detail (in the comment section) the supported db (MySQL,
PostgreSQL, Oracle,
+ SQLite, other) and their version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any relational
databases.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports a few relational databases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market
relational databases.</desc2>
+ <comment>mysql is the default but xwiki may run on all jdbc
drivers enabled databases.</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="xmldbms" title="xml database support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in XML
databases. Reminder:
+ here, a higher score does not mean a better product nor the
opposite, it really
+ depends on your needs and non functional requirements. If the
score is 1 or 2, do
+ detail (in the comment section) the supported db (BerkeleyDB ,
other) and their
+ version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any XML databases.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports a few XML databases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market XML
databases.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="odbms" title="object database support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
object (oriented)
+ databases. Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a
better product nor the
+ opposite, it really depends on your needs and non functional
requirements. If the
+ score is 1 or 2, do detail (in the comment section) the
supported db (ObjectDB,
+ Versant, Cache, other) and their version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any object databases.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports a few object databases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market object
databases.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="rcs" title="revision control system support">
+ <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
revision control system.
+ Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product
nor the opposite, it
+ really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
If the score is 1 or
+ 2, do detail (in the comment section) the supported db (CVS,
SVN, ClearCase, other)
+ and their version. </desc>
+ <desc0>The software does not support any rcs.</desc0>
+ <desc1>The software supports just one or a few rcs.</desc1>
+ <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market
rcs.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="datawarehouse" title="Data Warehouse">
+ <desc>Does the system support data warehousing?</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists with limitation (TODO)</desc1>
+ <desc2></desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="webcompatibility" title="Web compatibility">
+ <element name="webstandards" title="Standards">
+ <element name="htmlstandard" title="HTML">
+ <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
+ <desc0>Page not valid (parse errors)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Page not valid with important errors (encoding
mismatch)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Page valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute,
use of unknow attribute)</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="xhtmlstandard" title="XHTML">
+ <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
+ <desc0>Page not valid (parse errors)</desc0>
+ <desc1>Page not valid with important errors (encoding
mismatch)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Page valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute,
use of unknow attribute)</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="cssstandard" title="CSS">
+ <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
+ <desc0>CSS doesn't or no valid not valide (parse errors)</desc0>
+ <desc1>CSS not valid with important errors (encoding
mismatch)</desc1>
+ <desc2>CSS valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute,
use of unknow attribute)</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="webbestpractice" title="Best Practive">
+
<desc>http://developer.apple.com/internet/webcontent/bestwebdev.htmls</desc>
+ <element name="tablepsitioning" title="Table Positioning">
+ <desc>html tables should not be used for layout/positioning, css
is there to help.</desc>
+ <desc2>html tables are not used for layout/positioning</desc2>
+ <desc1>not too much used</desc1>
+ <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="frameuse" title="Frame use">
+ <desc>Frame use </desc>
+ <desc2>frame are not used</desc2>
+ <desc1>frame are rarely used</desc1>
+ <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="iframeuse" title="iFrame use">
+ <desc>iFrame use </desc>
+ <desc2>iframe are not used</desc2>
+ <desc1>iframe are rarely used</desc1>
+ <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="cssdesignedforprintout" title="css designed for
printout">
+ <desc>css designed for printout</desc>
+ <desc0>no</desc0>
+ <desc1>yes, but print-outs are not well rendered for a few use
cases.</desc1>
+ <desc2>yes</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="supportedbrowser" title="Supported Browser">
+ <element name="browsermozillafirefox" title="Mozilla and Firefox">
+ <desc>Firefox, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browserkonqueror" title="Konqueror">
+ <desc>Konqueror, please detail the supported version in the
comment section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browsermsie" title="MSIE">
+ <desc>MSIE, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browsersafari" title="Safari">
+ <desc>Safarie, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browserlegacy" title="legacy browsers">
+ <desc>Legacy browser are browser outdated like MSIE4 and Netscape
4,
+ please detail the supported version in the comment
section.</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
+ <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score></score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="browserrequiredenablings" title="Best Practive">
+ <desc>Browser required enablings: javascript, applet, SVG, and flash.
Reminder: here, a higher
+ score does not mean a better product nor the opposite, it
really depends on your needs and non
+ functional requirements. </desc>
+ <element name="javascriptrequired" title="Javascript required">
+ <desc> Is the browser javascript enabling required ? If the score
is 1 or 2, do indicate in
+ the comment section the required jvm version. If the score
is 1, do detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface makes no use of javascript, and thus, does
not need javascript to run at
+ full flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of javascript but can properly
function without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>Javascript is necessary to use the interface (beacuse it's
AJAX based for instance).</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="jvmrequired" title="a Java plugin is required">
+ <desc>Does the browser needs a java plugin (to enable applet) ? If
the score is 1 or 2, do
+ indicate in the comment section the required jvm version.
If the score is 1, do detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface does not contains any applet, and thus, does
not need java to run at full
+ flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of applet(s) but can properly
function without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A Java plugin is necessary to use the interface, the
applets are key players in it.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="svgrequired" title="a SVG plugin is required">
+ <desc> Does the browser needs a SVG plugin ? If score is 1 or 2,
do indicate in the comment
+ section the required SVG version. If the score is 1, do
detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface does not contains any SVG graph, and thus,
does not need any SVG plugin
+ to run at full flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of SVG but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A SVG plugin is necessary to use the interface, the SVG
graph are part of key features
+ of the interface.</desc2>
+ <comment>unless you want to use SVG, it's not required</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="flashrequired" title="a flash plugin is required">
+ <desc>Does the browser needs a flash plugin ? If score is 1 or 2,
do indicate in the comment
+ section the required flash version. If the score is 1, do
detail. </desc>
+ <desc0>The interface does not contains any flash graph, and thus,
does not need any flash
+ plugin to run at full flavor and speed </desc0>
+ <desc1>The interface makes use of flash but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A flash plugin is necessary to use the interface, the
interface is mainly made of
+ flash.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="UI" title="User interface">
+ <element name="i18nUI" title="internationalisation support">
+ <desc>
+ Is the whole user interface internationalizable ? Is Unicode
Supported ?
+ Are Right-to-Left languages supported (as for Hebrew and
Arabic) ?
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>Limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="skinableUI" title="skin-ability">
+ <desc>
+ Does the UI have a complete skin system ?
+ (a User/UserGroup customizable interface for instance)
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>Limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="webcontentmanagement" title="Web content management support">
+ <desc>This section describes the system's web content/attachement
management features.</desc>
+ <element name="metadata" title="Support for Meta data on content">
+ <desc>Meta data are information related to a document like (keywords,
category, author, copyright holder, ...)</desc>
+ <element name="keyword" title="Keyword support">
+ <desc>Metadata are all the specific keywords that can be attached
to a document (e.g:
+ sun, holydays, summer for a picture from your last
holydays)</desc>
+ <desc0>Can't add specific key word</desc0>
+ <desc1>Key word can be add but with limitation: limited list, no
easy to way extend the
+ list</desc1>
+ <desc2>Key word power are easy to add extend</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="hierarchicalclassification" title="Hierarchical
Classification">
+ <desc>Ability to do a classication in predesigned hierarchy,
category or namespaces</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exist but is limited.</desc1>
+ <desc2>A new document can quickly be registered in the
hierarchy</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="documentsupport" title="document types support">
+ <desc> Supported means that the internal engine is able to store and
eventually read or
+ parse file content in order to create preview file, find key words,
and thus use for
+ search, merge and diff</desc>
+ <element name="textcontent" title="text formats">
+ <element name="txt" title="text files">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview nor search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformathtml" title="HTML files">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview nor search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformatrtf" title="RTF (Rich Text Format)">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformatcsv" title="CSV">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="importformatxml" title="XML files">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
+ not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="opendocumentsupport" title="Opendocument (open office)
files support">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are supported
but parsing is not
+ (and consequently nor preview or search, diff, merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="msofficesupport" title="MS Office files support">
+ <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
+ parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are supported
but parsing is not
+ (and consequently nor preview or search, diff, merge)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="vectorialformat" title="common vectorial format">
+ <desc>Format are: wmf, svg</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>partialy (buggy or limited feature)</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="versioncontrol" title="On line version control">
+ <desc> The documents targeted by the version control are those listed
as fully supported in the above "documentsupport" elements </desc>
+ <element name="history" title="online access to each pages/docs (of
fully supported media) history/versioning">
+ <desc0>No history/versioning</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited number of document revisions</desc1>
+ <desc2>unlimited number of document revisions</desc2>
+ <comment>on wiki texts and attached docs</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="diff" title="online supports for version differencing
diff and retrieving prior versions.">
+ <desc0>No diff feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>Revision Diffs with the latest</desc1>
+ <desc2>Revision Diffs with the all</desc2>
+ <comment>on wiki texts only</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="rollback" title="online supports for
retrieving/rollbacking to prior versions.">
+ <desc0>No rollback feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>rollback to the latest</desc1>
+ <desc2>rollback to all</desc2>
+ <comment>on wiki pages only</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mergetools" title="tools to facilitate merge
pages/docs (of fully supported media).">
+ <desc0>No such merging tools</desc0>
+ <desc1>basic merge tools</desc1>
+ <desc2>smart merge tools</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="picture" title="picture formats support">
+ <desc>Supported means that the internal engine is able to store and
eventually make thumbnail/preview file</desc>
+ <element name="commonpictureformat" title="common file format">
+ <desc>Format are: jpg, gif, png, bmp, tiff, xpm, </desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="commercialpictureformat" title="commercial formats">
+ <desc>Format are: psp (PaintShopPro), psd (Photopshop)</desc>
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>supported</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="search" title="Support for search">
+ <desc>The metadata and media content support is to be detailed in the
above metadata and mediasupport elements </desc>
+ <element name="searchengine" title="Search Engine feature">
+ <desc0>No search engine available</desc0>
+ <desc1>Searches are limited (to filename, metadata or text content
for instance)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Searches are feasable through most of the media content and
the metadata</desc2>
+ <comment>the non fully supported format are not parsed in the
search</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="searchAPI" title="Search API for more detailed
searching in the contents and their meta-data">
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exist but is limited.</desc1>
+ <desc2>This feature is fully powered</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="updatenotification" title="Support for new content or
update notifications">
+ <element name="recentchanges" title="recent changes advertised on the
web interface">
+ <desc0>No such features</desc0>
+ <desc1>recent changes advertised according to the today's
date</desc1>
+ <desc2>recent changes advertised only changes that happened since
user's last visit</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="rss" title="support for rss feed">
+ <desc>Do detail the rss feed format/protocol in the comment
section</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>This feature exists and feeds are tunable and/or atom feeds
are available</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="othernotifications" title="support for other
notifications media">
+ <desc>Do detail the media in the comment section</desc>
+ <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists for one communication media</desc1>
+ <desc2>This feature exists for several media: e.mail, and IM for
instance </desc2>
+ <comment>easily do-able but not out of the bow</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="contentworkflow" title="Content management Workflow">
+ <element name="simpleLock" title="Simple Lock mechanism">
+ <desc>Ability to lock file avoid data lost or synchronization
issues</desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature just exists</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists, and administrator can quickly unlock a
file from an user. A time out system exists to unlock file after a certain
amount of time.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="workflow" title="Content management workflow">
+ <desc>Adding or updating a document in the system may be done
through a complex
+ workflow. Do detail in the comment section</desc>
+ <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature just exists, but the workflow is simple, a
single moderator system
+ for instance</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists, and the workflow is tunable.</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="pluginsandpluginability" title="Plugins, pluginability,
built-in objects, and page templates">
+ <element name="pluginability" title="plugin ability">
+ <desc>adequate software architecture for custom plugin creation,
easy plugin interface
+ for writing your own additions. Do detail in the comment section
the supported plugin languages </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="remoteAPI" title="XML/RPC Remote API">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>poor API</desc1>
+ <desc2>rich API</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="webserviceplugin" title="web service plugin">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited integration capabilities</desc1>
+ <desc2>good capabilities</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="feedagregation" title="ability to agregate feeds">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited integration capabilities</desc1>
+ <desc2>good capabilities</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="builtinobjects" title="builtin objects or plugins">
+ <element name="calendars" title="Calendars and Calendars events">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="blogs" title="blogs">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>A single blog is possible</desc1>
+ <desc2>multiple blogs supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="polls" title="polls and vote editing and
publishing">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment>easily do-able but not out of the box</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="photoalbums" title="photo albums editing and
publishing">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="slideshows" title="slide show editing and launching
within the internet browser">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="bugtrackingintegration" title="Bug tracking system
integration (tickets linking and meta data extraction)">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited integration: tickets linking </desc1>
+ <desc2>well supported: tickets linking and meta data
extraction</desc2>
+ <comment>easily do-able but not out of the box</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="otherplugins" title="other noticeable built-in
plugins">
+ <desc> others: FAQ, meeting minutes, Action Tracker plugin,
bookmarklet,
+ Geolocalisation features: GeoURL or googleMaps plugins,
Tagging and Tag clouds
+ (delicio.us, technorati, others), etc. Do list the plugins in
the comment section. </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>a few other plugins </desc1>
+ <desc2>many other plugins</desc2>
+ <comment>flickr, googlemap, etc...</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="wikipagelinks" title="wiki page creating, naming, linking,
listing and statistics">
+ <element name="pagenaming" title="page creation/naming and linking">
+ <desc> the wiki pages (or documents) can be viewed, created or edited
at anytime by
+ anyone from a web browser (with certain limitations for
protected areas cf. the
+ websecurity section ). </desc>
+ <desc0>The wiki page are only created and accessible through
CamelCase links</desc0>
+ <desc1>the wiki supports free links</desc1>
+ <desc2>the wiki supports free links and image links</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="discussion" title="Each pages has a comments/discussions
area">
+ <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>supported : access to a discussion/comment area particular to
that page</desc1>
+ <desc2>fine grained discussion supported : possible to comment the
page by section</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="pagelists" title="wiki pages administration and
navigation lists">
+ <element name="availablepageslisting" title="list of all available
pages">
+ <desc> list of all the existing pages (and pages within the
hierarchy, if the
+ hierarchy is supported, cf. webcontentmanagement section)
</desc>
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="backlinks" title="Backlinks: list of all the pages
linking back to the current one">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="undefinedpages" title="Undefined Pages : pages that
are referred to, but not yet created">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="orphanedpages" title="Orphaned Pages : not currently
referred to by any other page, thus meaning they are inaccessible through any
other means">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="lockedpages" title="Lock pages: currently hold for
editing pages, if the Lock is supported, cf. webcontentmanagement section">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="wantedpages" title="Wanted Pages: list of all the
pages wanted for creation by the users">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mostleastpopularpages" title="Most/Least Popular
pages">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="recentlyvisitedpages" title="Recently visited pages">
+ <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
+ <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
+ <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="pageediting" title="page editing features">
+ <element name="onlinepageediting" title="online page editing">
+ <desc> All the pages (or documents) can edited at anytime by anyone
from a web browser,
+ (with certain limitations for protected areas cf. the
websecurity section ). The
+ following element details the editing features. </desc>
+ <desc0>Not supported, it's not a wiki</desc0>
+ <desc1>n.a. </desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="i18nofdocuments" title="i18n of documents :
Internationalization and Multilingual capability for documents">
+ <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support: unicode, nor Right-to-Left Support (as for
Hebrew and Arabic)
+ are supported </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully implemented</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="wikisyntax" title="wiki syntax or wikitext features">
+ <desc> The following features list is supposed to show the ease of
learning and using:
+ writing, reading and modifying wiki pages </desc>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <element name="lightweightmarkuplanguage" title="light weight markup
language support">
+ <desc> the most known light weight markup language are : CREOLE
+ (http://www.wikicreole.org/wiki/Home), BBCode
+ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode), Textile
+
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textile_%28markup_language%29), Markdown
+ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown), BBCode
+ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode), Radeox API
+ (http://radeox.org/space/start) </desc>
+ <desc0>this wiki has a very specific or very poor syntax</desc0>
+ <desc1>this wiki has a uncommon or poor syntax </desc1>
+ <desc2>this wiki support a standard and rich light weight markup
language</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="tableedition" title="Tables edition ease: simple and
complex (colspan and rowspan) table support">
+ <desc0>not implemented</desc0>
+ <desc1>implemented but with a limited API, simple tables
only</desc1>
+ <desc2>implemented exhaustively, simple and complex (colspan and
rowspan) table
+ support</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="htmltags" title="HTML Tags allowed">
+ <desc0>not allowed</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="toc" title="TOC (Table of content) Auto-generation">
+ <desc0>not implemented</desc0>
+ <desc1>implemented but with a poor API</desc1>
+ <desc2>implemented exhaustively</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="wikicomments" title="Internal Comments / comments in
the wiki page code">
+ <desc0>not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>n.a.</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="otherspecialsyntax" title="other specialized wiki
syntax">
+ <desc> support for footnotes, quote, interwiki links, emoticon and
other icon rendering
+ through syntax. Do list in the comment section. </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>a few other syntax/editing plugin </desc1>
+ <desc2>many others</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="pageeditingusability" title="page editing Usability">
+ <desc> Does the wiki provides the following features: Preview before
saving; Section
+ Editing or whole page only editing; Double-Click on the text
to Edit; access Keys
+ (to save, edit, quit ...) ; different editor are supported
(some with editing
+ Toolbar); a fully WYSIWYG editor is available. Do detail the
available features in
+ the comment section. </desc>
+ <desc0>very limited features</desc0>
+ <desc1>a few of those features are available</desc1>
+ <desc2>all those features are available</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="spellchecker" title="spell checker">
+ <desc>Useless feature if you use a decent browser like firefox2 that
contains an inline spell checking:
+ a built-in spell checker enables users to quickly check the
spelling of text entered into Web forms
+ (like this one) without having to use a seperate application.
+ </desc>
+ <desc0>no spell checker availble or it's just based on a too limited
dictionary that make it
+ being a wast of time</desc0>
+ <desc1>working dictionnary but limited (e.g: grammar not included,
false positive, hard to
+ extend)</desc1>
+ <desc2>Powerful dictionary</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="contentincludes" title="Content Includes : Inclusion of
pages inside another wiki page">
+ <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support</desc1>
+ <desc2>supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="flagging" title="editing flags features : meta data added
by the commiters when editing">
+ <desc> Those features are not that usefull when the
pagesversioncontrol is well
+ designed, they can be things like: "Minor Changes flagging"
feature, or "Change
+ Summary" features </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited features</desc1>
+ <desc2>exhaustive features</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="advancededitingfeatures" title="Advanced editing
features">
+ <element name="templating" title="MetaData Form and templating
ability">
+ <desc> Design Engine for Meta-Data and Forms, allowing to design
custom forms with
+ text fields, textarea fields, number fields, static select
fields API to display
+ meta-data in view and edit mode inside the Wiki page. (to
create custom forms
+ and templates and In-place (inline) editing of form
information in pages). </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited features</desc1>
+ <desc2>exhaustive features with a rich API</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="codesyntaxhighlighting" title="Code Syntax
Highlighting">
+ <desc> hightlight (colorize) source code snippets when added to a
wikipage </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>present but minimal</desc1>
+ <desc2>very well supported: colorize according to code/language
specifications</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="mathformulas" title="support for Math formulas edition
and display">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported and standard : LaTeX syntac support: to
edit mathematical
+ formulas in Latex syntax directly in the Wiki and display
them as images</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="tableplugins" title="plugins associated with wiki
table syntax">
+ <element name="tablesorting" title="Table sorting plugin">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>0</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="spreadsheet" title="Add spreadsheet formulae like
$SUM($ABOVE()) to tables">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="chartplugin" title="ChartPlugin : charts creation
from wiki tables">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
+ <desc2>well done</desc2>
+ <comment>not officially released yet</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="media" title="media editing features">
+ <desc> support for Image Editing (applet for instance) or other
media in-line editor
+ (SVG, MindMap ...) </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>one or two editing capabilities like these </desc1>
+ <desc2>many capabilities</desc2>
+ <comment>svg and mindmap in progress</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </element>
+ <element name="wikiscripting" title="scripting/programming ability
within the wiki page code">
+ <desc> programming API to create custom dynamic web applications only
using the Wiki
+ interface. Do detail in the comment section the supported wiki
scripting languages. </desc>
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited API </desc1>
+ <desc2>rich API</desc2>
+ <comment>groovy and velocity script ability</comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+ <section name="pagesexport" title="wiki pages exports">
+ <desc> RSS feeds are already described in the webcontentmanagement
include/section. Here we
+ list the other export kinds. </desc>
+ <element name="rawexport" title="raw export: wiki page as coded">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="htmlexport" title="page HTML Export (without the wiki
navigation element)">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="xmlexport" title="page XML export">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment></comment>
+ <score>2</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="pdfexport" title="page PDF export">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment>a bit buggy</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ <element name="customoutput" title="custom output plugin-ability (RSS,
FOAF)">
+ <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
+ <desc1>limited support </desc1>
+ <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
+ <comment>in progress</comment>
+ <score>1</score>
+ </element>
+ </section>
+</document>
\ No newline at end of file
Index: xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
===================================================================
RCS file: xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
diff -N xwiki-0.9.840.qsos
--- xwiki-0.9.840.qsos 26 Oct 2006 15:25:44 -0000 1.3
+++ /dev/null 1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
@@ -1,1435 +0,0 @@
-<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
-<document>
- <header>
- <authors> Francois Le Droff </authors>
- <dates>
- <creation></creation>
- <validation></validation>
- </dates>
- <language>en</language>
- <appname>xwiki</appname>
- <release>0.9.840</release>
- <licenseid>32</licenseid>
- <licensedesc>GNU LGPL</licensedesc>
- <url>http://www.xwiki.org</url>
- <desc></desc>
- <demourl>http://www.xwiki.org</demourl>
- <qsosformat>1.6</qsosformat>
- <qsosappfamily>wiki</qsosappfamily>
- <qsosspecificformat></qsosspecificformat>
- </header>
- <section name="generic" title="Generic section">
- <desc>Generic criteria from QSOS version 1.6</desc>
- <element name="intrinsicdurability" title="Intrinsic durability">
- <desc>Intrinsic durability</desc>
- <element name="maturity" title="Maturity">
- <desc>Maturity</desc>
- <element name="age" title="Age">
- <desc0>less than 3 months</desc0>
- <desc1>if between 3 months and 3 years</desc1>
- <desc2>after 3 years</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="stability" title="Stability">
- <desc0>Unstable software with numerous releases or patches
generating side effects</desc0>
- <desc1>Stabilized production release existing but old.
Difficulties to stabilize developpement releases</desc1>
- <desc2>Stabilized software. Releases provide bug fixes
corrections but mainly new functionalities</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="historyknowproblems" title="History, know problems">
- <desc0>Software knows several problems which can be
prohibitive</desc0>
- <desc1>No know major problem or crisis</desc1>
- <desc2>History of good management of crisis situations</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="forkprobability" title="Fork probability, source of
Forking">
- <desc0>Software is very likely to be forked in the
future</desc0>
- <desc1>Software comes from a fork but has very few chances of
being forked in the future</desc1>
- <desc2>Software has very little chance of being forked. It does
not come from a fork either</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="adoption" title="Adoption">
- <desc>Adoption by community and industry</desc>
- <element name="popularity" title="Popularity (related to: general
public, niche, ...)">
- <desc0>Very few users identified</desc0>
- <desc1>Detectable use on Internet</desc1>
- <desc2>Numerous users, numerous references</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="references" title="References">
- <desc0>None</desc0>
- <desc1>Few refences, non critical usages</desc1>
- <desc2>Often implemented for critical applications</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="contributingcommunity" title="Contributing
Community">
- <desc0>No community or without real activity (forum, mailing
list, ...)</desc0>
- <desc1>Existing community with a notable activity</desc1>
- <desc2>Strong community: big activity on forums, numerous
contributors and advocates</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="books" title="books">
- <desc0>No book about the software</desc0>
- <desc1>Less than 5 books about the software are
available</desc1>
- <desc2>More than 5 books about software are available, in
several languages</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="developmentleadership" title="Development leadership">
- <desc>Organisation and leadership of developments</desc>
- <element name="leadingteam" title="Leading team">
- <desc0>1 to 2 individuals involved, not clearly
identified</desc0>
- <desc1>Between 2 and 5 independent people</desc1>
- <desc2>More than 5 people</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment>5 admins</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="managementstyle" title="Management style">
- <desc0>Complete dictatorship</desc0>
- <desc1>Enlightened despotism</desc1>
- <desc2>Council of architects with identified leader (e.g:
KDE)</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment>Out of 5 Admins, Ludovic Dubost, Jeremi Joslin and
Vincent Massol are the main drivers.</comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="activity" title="Activity">
- <desc>Activity of the project and around the software</desc>
- <element name="developersidentificationturnover"
title="Developers, identification, turnover">
- <desc0>Less than 3 developers, not clearly identified</desc0>
- <desc1>Between 4 and 7 developers, or more unidentified
developers with important turnover</desc1>
- <desc2>More than 7 developers, very stable team</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment>56 developpers</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="activityonbugs" title="Activity on bugs">
- <desc0>Slow reactivity in forum or on mailing list, or nothing
regarding bug fixes in releases note</desc0>
- <desc1>Detectable activity but without process clearly exposed,
loing reaction/resolution time</desc1>
- <desc2>Strong reactivity based on roles and tasks
assignment</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment>the process is clearly exposed (mainly through jira),
the resolution are not always fast</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="activityonfunctionalities" title="Activity on
functionalities">
- <desc0>No or few new functionalities</desc0>
- <desc1>Evolution of the product driven by the core team or by
user's request without any clearly explained process</desc1>
- <desc2>Tool(s) to manage feature requests, strong interaction
with roadmap</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="activityonreleases" title="Activity on releases">
- <desc0>Very weak activity on both production and development
releases</desc0>
- <desc1>Activity on production and developmenet releases.
Frequent minor releases (bug fixes)</desc1>
- <desc2>Important activity with frequent minor releases (bugs
fixes) and planned major releases relating to the roadmap forcast</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="industrializedsolution" title="Industrialized solution">
- <desc>Industrialization level of the project</desc>
- <element name="independenceofdevelopments" title="Independence of
developments">
- <desc0>Developments realized at 100% by employees of a single
company</desc0>
- <desc1>60% maximum</desc1>
- <desc2>20% maximum</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment>The core developpers are in Ludovic Dubost team, He is
the founder of Xpernet, the xwiki editor.</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="services" title="Services">
- <desc>Services offering</desc>
- <element name="training" title="Training">
- <desc0>No offer of training identified</desc0>
- <desc1>Offer exists but is restricted geographically and to one
language or is provided by a single contractor</desc1>
- <desc2>Rich offers provided by several contractors, in serveral
languages and split into modules of gradual levels</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
-
<comment>http://www.xwiki.com/xwiki/bin/view/Company/Training+Services</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="support" title="Support">
- <desc0>No offer of support except via public forums and mailing
lists</desc0>
- <desc1>Offer exists but is provided by a single contractor
without strong commitment quality of services</desc1>
- <desc2>Multiple service providers with strong commitment (e.g:
guaranteed resolution time)</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
-
<comment>http://www.xwiki.com/xwiki/bin/view/Company/Support+Contracts
-</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="consulting" title="Consulting">
- <desc0>No offer of consulting service</desc0>
- <desc1>Offer exists but is restricted geographically and to one
language or is provided by a single contractor</desc1>
- <desc2>Consulting services provided by different contractors in
serveral languages</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
-
<comment>http://www.xwiki.com/xwiki/bin/view/Company/Development+and+Consulting</comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="documentation" title="Documentation">
- <desc0>No user documentation</desc0>
- <desc1>Documentation exists but shifted in time, is restricted to
one language or is poorly detailed</desc1>
- <desc2>Documentation always up to date, translated and possibly
adapted to different target readers (end user, sysadmin, manager, ...)</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="qualityassurance" title="Quality Assurance">
- <desc>Quality assurance process</desc>
- <element name="quality" title="Quality Assurance">
- <desc0>No QA process</desc0>
- <desc1>Identifies QA process but not much formalized and with
no tool</desc1>
- <desc2>Automatic testing process included in code's life-cycle
with publication of results</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="tools" title="Tools">
- <desc0>No bug or feature request management tool</desc0>
- <desc1>Standard tools provided (for instance by a hosting
forge) but poorly used</desc1>
- <desc2>Very active use of tools for roles/tasks allocation and
progress monitoring</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment>svn, maven, ant, forge objectweb, jira.org,
xwiki.org</comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="packaging" title="Packaging">
- <desc>Packaging for various operating systems</desc>
- <element name="packagingsource" title="Source">
- <desc0>Software can't be installed from source without lot of
work</desc0>
- <desc1>Installation from source is limited and depends on very
strict conditions (OS, arch, lib, ...)</desc1>
- <desc2>Installation from source is easy</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingdebian" title="Debian">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for Debian</desc0>
- <desc1>A Debian package exists but it has important issues or
it doesn't have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingfreebsd" title="FreeBSD">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for FreeBSD</desc0>
- <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't
have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>A official port exists in FreeBSD</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packaginghpux" title="HP-UX">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for HP-UX</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>A stable package is provided for HP-UX</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingmacosx" title="MacOSX">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for MacOSX</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingmandriva" title="Mandriva">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for Mandriva</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingnet" title="NetBSD">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for NetBSD</desc0>
- <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't
have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>A official port exists in NetBSD</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingopen" title="OpenBSD">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for OpenBSD</desc0>
- <desc1>A port exists but it has important issues or it doesn't
have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>A official port exists in OpenBSD</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingredhat" title="RedHat">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for RedHat/Fedora</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingsolaris" title="Solaris">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for Solaris</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support (e.g: SunFreeware.com )</desc1>
- <desc2>The software is supported by Sun for Solaris</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingsuse" title="SuSE">
- <desc0>The software is not packaged for SuSE</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it has important issues or it
doesn't have official support</desc1>
- <desc2>The software is packaged in the distribution</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="packagingwindows" title="Windows">
- <desc0>The project can't be installed on Windows</desc0>
- <desc1>A package exists but it is limited or has important
issues or just cover some specific Windows release (e.g: Windows2000 and
WindowsXP)</desc1>
- <desc2>Windows is full supported and a package is
provided</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment>There's a zip with mysql tomcat and xwiki bundled
together.</comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="exploitability" title="Exploitability">
- <desc>Exploitability level</desc>
- <element name="easeofuseergonomics" title="Ease of use, ergonomics">
- <desc0>Difficult to use, requires an in depth knowledge of the
software functionality</desc0>
- <desc1>Austere and very technical ergonomics</desc1>
- <desc2>GUI including help functions and elaborated
ergonomics</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="administrationmonitoring" title="Administration /
Monitoring">
- <desc0>No administrative or monitoring functionalities</desc0>
- <desc1>Existing, functionalities but uncomplete and or need
improvement</desc1>
- <desc2>Complete and easy-to-use administration and monitoring
functionalities. Possible integration with external tools (e.g: SNMP, syslog,
...)</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="technicaladaptability" title="Technical adaptability">
- <desc>Technical adaptability</desc>
- <element name="modularity" title="Modularity">
- <desc0>Monolithic software</desc0>
- <desc1>Presence of hight level modules allowing a first level of
software adaptation</desc1>
- <desc2>Modular conception, allowing easy adaptation of the
software by selecting or creating modules</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="codemodification" title="Code modification">
- <desc0>Everything by hand</desc0>
- <desc1>Recompilation possible but complex without any tools or
documentation</desc1>
- <desc2>Recompilation with tools (e.g: make, ANT, ...) and
documentation provided</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="codeextension" title="Code extention">
- <desc0>Any modification requires code recompilation</desc0>
- <desc1>Architecture designed for static extension but requires
recompilation</desc1>
- <desc2>Principle of plugin, architecture designed for dynamic
extension without recompilation</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="strategy" title="Strategy">
- <desc>Project's strategy</desc>
- <element name="license" title="License">
- <desc>License</desc>
- <element name="permissiveness" title="Permissiveness (only if user
wants to become owner of code)">
- <desc0>Very strict license, like GPL</desc0>
- <desc1>Moderate permissive license located between both
extremes (GPL and BSD) dual-licensing depending on the type of user (person,
company, ...) or their activities</desc1>
- <desc2>Very permissive like BSD or Apache licenses</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="protectionagainstproprietaryforks"
title="Protection against proprietary forks">
- <desc0>Very permissive like BSD or Apache licenses</desc0>
- <desc1>Moderate permissive license located between both
extremes (GPL and BSD), dual-licensing depending on the type of user (person,
company, ...) or their activies</desc1>
- <desc2>Very strict license, like GPL</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="copyrightowners" title="Copyright owners">
- <desc0>Rights held by a few individuals or entities, making it
easier to change the license</desc0>
- <desc1>Rights held by numerous individuals owning the code in a
homogeneous way, making relicense very difficult</desc1>
- <desc2>Rights held by a legal entity in whom the community trusts
(e.g: FSF or ASF)</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment>Copyright 2006, XpertNet SARL, and individual
contributors as indicated by the contributors.txt.</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="modificationofsourcecode" title="Modification of
source code">
- <desc0>No pratical way to propose code modification</desc0>
- <desc1>Tools provided to access and modify code (like CVS or SVN)
but not really used to develop the software</desc1>
- <desc2>The code modification process is well defined, exposed and
respected, based on roles assignment</desc2>
- <score>2</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- <element name="roadmap" title="Roadmap">
- <desc0>No published roadmap</desc0>
- <desc1>Existing roadmap without planning</desc1>
- <desc2>Versionned roadmap, with planning and measure of
delays</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment>http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Dev/Roadmap and on
Jira
-</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="sponsor" title="Sponsor">
- <desc0>Software has no sponsor, the core team is not paid</desc0>
- <desc1>Software has an unique sponsor who might determine its
strategy</desc1>
- <desc2>Software is sponsored by industry</desc2>
- <score>1</score>
- <comment>The unique sponsor is xpernet, but the project is part of
ObjectWeb</comment>
- </element>
- <element name="strategicalindependence" title="Strategical
independence">
- <desc0>No detectable strategy or strong dependency on one unique
actor (person, company, sponsor)</desc0>
- <desc1>Strategical vision shared with several other free and open
source projects but without strong commitment from copyrights owners</desc1>
- <desc2>Strong independence of the code team, legal entity holding
rights, strong involvement in the standardization process</desc2>
- <score>0</score>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="webappprerequisite" title="web application prerequisites">
- <element name="platform" title="platform on which the web application is
running">
- <desc>Detail here the platform details and implementation language(s)
and its(their) version
- </desc>
- <element name="j2eeplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a j2ee platform?">
- <desc>Detail in the comment section the J2EE or JavaEE
specifications used an their versions as well as the supported servers.
- </desc>
- <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
- <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
- <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
- <comment>all servlet containers should be able to run it.
-It's based on many standard os java library like hibernate,
velocity....</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="phpplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a php platform?">
- <desc>Detail in the comment section php versions and the supported
servers.
- </desc>
- <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
- <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
- <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="cgiplatform" title="Is the web application running on
a cgi platform?">
- <desc>Detail in the comment section cgi versions and the supported
servers.
- </desc>
- <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
- <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
- <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="mod_perlplatform" title="Is the web application
running on a mod_perl platform?">
- <desc>Detail in the comment section cgi versions and the supported
servers.
- </desc>
- <desc0>the web app is not running on this platform</desc0>
- <desc1>support a limited number of servers</desc1>
- <desc2>may run on many servers, respect platform standards</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <comment></comment>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="websecurity" title="Security for web application">
- <element name="authentifaction" title="Authentification Backend">
- <element name="authenbackendldap" title="LDAP">
- <desc0>No LDAP based authentification available</desc0>
- <desc1>LDAP available but limited (e.g: group mapping limited,
etc)</desc1>
- <desc2>LDAP is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="authenbackendad" title="Active Directory">
- <desc0>No Active Directory based authentification available</desc0>
- <desc1>Active Directory available but limited (e.g: group mapping
limited, etc)</desc1>
- <desc2>Active Directory is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="authenbackenddb" title="data base">
- <desc>Here we do not attach importance on supported data bases,
please see the
- storage support section</desc>
- <desc0>No data base base authentification availble</desc0>
- <desc1>Data base available but limited (e.g: group mapping
limited, etc)</desc1>
- <desc2>Data base is one of the recommended authentification
backend</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="usersrightsmanagement" title="User Rights Management">
- <element name="accessrights" title="access rights management">
- <desc>
- Does the system support access rights:
- to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users on the overall system
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature is not supported, every user has the same
capabilities</desc0>
- <desc1>Feature is partialy supported, but not fine grained</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature is supported, and the capabilities are exhaustive
according to the system capabilities.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="usersgroups" title="User group's management">
- <desc>
- Does the system support users group and thus, users group
access rights management:
- to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users groups ?
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Feature is partially supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="spaceaccessrights" title="Space access rights
management">
- <desc>
- Is the web content dividable in subparts, spaces ?
- Does the system support access rights for those spaces:
- to control the capabilities (comment, view, edit, delete,
compute, script...) of each users
- (and users group, if they are supported. ) on specific
space/sub-part of the system ?
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature is not supported, the system is not divided in
spaces</desc0>
- <desc1>Feature is partially supported, but not fine grained</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature is fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="antispammingandvandalism" title="anti spamming and
vandalism features">
- <element name="hostblocking" title="Host Blocking">
- <desc>
- Host Blocking : Deny access from IP list
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="blacklist" title="Black List">
- <desc>
- Blacklist (of known URL ,word or content to associate with
spam)
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="captcha" title="CAPTCHA">
- <desc>
- CAPTCHA : to diffenciate a robot from an anonymous user
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature is not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Feature is partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature is supported</desc2>
- <comment>captcha is available through a plugin</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="robotscontrol" title="robots and search engine control
features">
- <desc>
- robots and search engine control features, such as :
- nofollow (external links tags with rel="nofollow");
- Delayed Indexing (of search engine, to have time to track down
the spam and vandalism).
- Do Detail in the comment section.
- </desc>
- <desc0>No such features</desc0>
- <desc1>Limited features</desc1>
- <desc2>Such features are supported</desc2>
- <comment>easily do-able</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="signatureandcontentprotection" title="other signature and
content protection features">
- <element name="signaturemechansim" title="Signing">
- <desc>support for digital cypher (e.g: GNU PGP)</desc>
- <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="digitalwatermarking" title="Digital watermarking">
- <desc>
- Digital watermarking is a technique which allows an individual
- to add hidden copyright notices or other verification messages
- to digital audio, video, or image signals and documents
- </desc>
- <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="DRM" title="DRM">
- <desc></desc>
- <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="mailencryption" title="Mail Encryption">
- <desc></desc>
- <desc0>Feature not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>Fetautre partialy supported</desc1>
- <desc2>Feature fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="storagesupport" title="Storage support">
- <element name="file system" title="file system storage">
- <desc>
- The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in (flat) files in
the file system.
- Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product nor the
opposite,
- it really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
- </desc>
- <desc0>The data persisted by the software cant be stored in
flatfiles</desc0>
- <desc1>The data persisted by the software can be stored in flatfiles,
though it's not the default option.</desc1>
- <desc2>The data persisted by the software is only stored in
flatfiles</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="database" title="Data Base">
- <element name="rdbms" title="relational database support">
- <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
relational databases.
- Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product
nor the opposite, it
- really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
If the score is 1 or
- 2, do detail (in the comment section) the supported db (MySQL,
PostgreSQL, Oracle,
- SQLite, other) and their version. </desc>
- <desc0>The software does not support any relational
databases.</desc0>
- <desc1>The software supports a few relational databases.</desc1>
- <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market
relational databases.</desc2>
- <comment>mysql is the default but xwiki may run on all jdbc
drivers enabled databases.</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="xmldbms" title="xml database support">
- <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in XML
databases. Reminder:
- here, a higher score does not mean a better product nor the
opposite, it really
- depends on your needs and non functional requirements. If the
score is 1 or 2, do
- detail (in the comment section) the supported db (BerkeleyDB ,
other) and their
- version. </desc>
- <desc0>The software does not support any XML databases.</desc0>
- <desc1>The software supports a few XML databases.</desc1>
- <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market XML
databases.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="odbms" title="object database support">
- <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
object (oriented)
- databases. Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a
better product nor the
- opposite, it really depends on your needs and non functional
requirements. If the
- score is 1 or 2, do detail (in the comment section) the
supported db (ObjectDB,
- Versant, Cache, other) and their version. </desc>
- <desc0>The software does not support any object databases.</desc0>
- <desc1>The software supports a few object databases.</desc1>
- <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market object
databases.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="rcs" title="revision control system support">
- <desc> The data persisted by the software can-be/is stored in
revision control system.
- Reminder: here, a higher score does not mean a better product
nor the opposite, it
- really depends on your needs and non functional requirements.
If the score is 1 or
- 2, do detail (in the comment section) the supported db (CVS,
SVN, ClearCase, other)
- and their version. </desc>
- <desc0>The software does not support any rcs.</desc0>
- <desc1>The software supports just one or a few rcs.</desc1>
- <desc2>The software supports all (or most) of the market
rcs.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="datawarehouse" title="Data Warehouse">
- <desc>Does the system support data warehousing?</desc>
- <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists with limitation (TODO)</desc1>
- <desc2></desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="webcompatibility" title="Web compatibility">
- <element name="webstandards" title="Standards">
- <element name="htmlstandard" title="HTML">
- <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
- <desc0>Page not valid (parse errors)</desc0>
- <desc1>Page not valid with important errors (encoding
mismatch)</desc1>
- <desc2>Page valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute,
use of unknow attribute)</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="xhtmlstandard" title="XHTML">
- <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
- <desc0>Page not valid (parse errors)</desc0>
- <desc1>Page not valid with important errors (encoding
mismatch)</desc1>
- <desc2>Page valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute,
use of unknow attribute)</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="cssstandard" title="CSS">
- <desc>http://validator.w3.org</desc>
- <desc0>CSS doesn't or no valid not valide (parse errors)</desc0>
- <desc1>CSS not valid with important errors (encoding
mismatch)</desc1>
- <desc2>CSS valid, or with minor errors (missing "alt" attribute,
use of unknow attribute)</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="webbestpractice" title="Best Practive">
-
<desc>http://developer.apple.com/internet/webcontent/bestwebdev.htmls</desc>
- <element name="tablepsitioning" title="Table Positioning">
- <desc>html tables should not be used for layout/positioning, css
is there to help.</desc>
- <desc2>html tables are not used for layout/positioning</desc2>
- <desc1>not too much used</desc1>
- <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="frameuse" title="Frame use">
- <desc>Frame use </desc>
- <desc2>frame are not used</desc2>
- <desc1>frame are rarely used</desc1>
- <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="iframeuse" title="iFrame use">
- <desc>iFrame use </desc>
- <desc2>iframe are not used</desc2>
- <desc1>iframe are rarely used</desc1>
- <desc0>systematically, too much used</desc0>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="cssdesignedforprintout" title="css designed for
printout">
- <desc>css designed for printout</desc>
- <desc0>no</desc0>
- <desc1>yes, but print-outs are not well rendered for a few use
cases.</desc1>
- <desc2>yes</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="supportedbrowser" title="Supported Browser">
- <element name="browsermozillafirefox" title="Mozilla and Firefox">
- <desc>Firefox, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
- <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
- <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
- <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="browserkonqueror" title="Konqueror">
- <desc>Konqueror, please detail the supported version in the
comment section</desc>
- <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
- <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
- <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score></score>
- </element>
- <element name="browsermsie" title="MSIE">
- <desc>MSIE, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
- <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
- <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
- <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="browsersafari" title="Safari">
- <desc>Safarie, please detail the supported version in the comment
section</desc>
- <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
- <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
- <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score></score>
- </element>
- <element name="browserlegacy" title="legacy browsers">
- <desc>Legacy browser are browser outdated like MSIE4 and Netscape
4,
- please detail the supported version in the comment
section.</desc>
- <desc0>not supported at all</desc0>
- <desc1>not officially supported, but works ok or good
enough.</desc1>
- <desc2>supported and advised browser</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score></score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="browserrequiredenablings" title="Best Practive">
- <desc>Browser required enablings: javascript, applet, SVG, and flash.
Reminder: here, a higher
- score does not mean a better product nor the opposite, it
really depends on your needs and non
- functional requirements. </desc>
- <element name="javascriptrequired" title="Javascript required">
- <desc> Is the browser javascript enabling required ? If the score
is 1 or 2, do indicate in
- the comment section the required jvm version. If the score
is 1, do detail. </desc>
- <desc0>The interface makes no use of javascript, and thus, does
not need javascript to run at
- full flavor and speed </desc0>
- <desc1>The interface makes use of javascript but can properly
function without it.</desc1>
- <desc2>Javascript is necessary to use the interface (beacuse it's
AJAX based for instance).</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="jvmrequired" title="a Java plugin is required">
- <desc>Does the browser needs a java plugin (to enable applet) ? If
the score is 1 or 2, do
- indicate in the comment section the required jvm version.
If the score is 1, do detail. </desc>
- <desc0>The interface does not contains any applet, and thus, does
not need java to run at full
- flavor and speed </desc0>
- <desc1>The interface makes use of applet(s) but can properly
function without it.</desc1>
- <desc2>A Java plugin is necessary to use the interface, the
applets are key players in it.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="svgrequired" title="a SVG plugin is required">
- <desc> Does the browser needs a SVG plugin ? If score is 1 or 2,
do indicate in the comment
- section the required SVG version. If the score is 1, do
detail. </desc>
- <desc0>The interface does not contains any SVG graph, and thus,
does not need any SVG plugin
- to run at full flavor and speed </desc0>
- <desc1>The interface makes use of SVG but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
- <desc2>A SVG plugin is necessary to use the interface, the SVG
graph are part of key features
- of the interface.</desc2>
- <comment>unless you want to use SVG, it's not required</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="flashrequired" title="a flash plugin is required">
- <desc>Does the browser needs a flash plugin ? If score is 1 or 2,
do indicate in the comment
- section the required flash version. If the score is 1, do
detail. </desc>
- <desc0>The interface does not contains any flash graph, and thus,
does not need any flash
- plugin to run at full flavor and speed </desc0>
- <desc1>The interface makes use of flash but can properly function
without it.</desc1>
- <desc2>A flash plugin is necessary to use the interface, the
interface is mainly made of
- flash.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="UI" title="User interface">
- <element name="i18nUI" title="internationalisation support">
- <desc>
- Is the whole user interface internationalizable ? Is Unicode
Supported ?
- Are Right-to-Left languages supported (as for Hebrew and
Arabic) ?
- </desc>
- <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>Limited support</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="skinableUI" title="skin-ability">
- <desc>
- Does the UI have a complete skin system ?
- (a User/UserGroup customizable interface for instance)
- </desc>
- <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>Limited support</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="webcontentmanagement" title="Web content management support">
- <desc>This section describes the system's web content/attachement
management features.</desc>
- <element name="metadata" title="Support for Meta data on content">
- <desc>Meta data are information related to a document like (keywords,
category, author, copyright holder, ...)</desc>
- <element name="keyword" title="Keyword support">
- <desc>Metadata are all the specific keywords that can be attached
to a document (e.g:
- sun, holydays, summer for a picture from your last
holydays)</desc>
- <desc0>Can't add specific key word</desc0>
- <desc1>Key word can be add but with limitation: limited list, no
easy to way extend the
- list</desc1>
- <desc2>Key word power are easy to add extend</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="hierarchicalclassification" title="Hierarchical
Classification">
- <desc>Ability to do a classication in predesigned hierarchy,
category or namespaces</desc>
- <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exist but is limited.</desc1>
- <desc2>A new document can quickly be registered in the
hierarchy</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="documentsupport" title="document types support">
- <desc> Supported means that the internal engine is able to store and
eventually read or
- parse file content in order to create preview file, find key words,
and thus use for
- search, merge and diff</desc>
- <element name="textcontent" title="text formats">
- <element name="txt" title="text files">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
- not (and consequently nor preview nor search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="importformathtml" title="HTML files">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
- not (and consequently nor preview nor search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="importformatrtf" title="RTF (Rich Text Format)">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
- not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="importformatcsv" title="CSV">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
- not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="importformatxml" title="XML files">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are
supported but parsing is
- not (and consequently nor preview or search, diff,
merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="opendocumentsupport" title="Opendocument (open office)
files support">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are supported
but parsing is not
- (and consequently nor preview or search, diff, merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="msofficesupport" title="MS Office files support">
- <desc>If score is 1 or 2, do detail in the comment section the
supported features :
- parsing, previewing, reading, searching</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partially: for instance: storing and metadata are supported
but parsing is not
- (and consequently nor preview or search, diff, merge)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="vectorialformat" title="common vectorial format">
- <desc>Format are: wmf, svg</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>partialy (buggy or limited feature)</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="versioncontrol" title="On line version control">
- <desc> The documents targeted by the version control are those listed
as fully supported in the above "documentsupport" elements </desc>
- <element name="history" title="online access to each pages/docs (of
fully supported media) history/versioning">
- <desc0>No history/versioning</desc0>
- <desc1>limited number of document revisions</desc1>
- <desc2>unlimited number of document revisions</desc2>
- <comment>on wiki texts and attached docs</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="diff" title="online supports for version differencing
diff and retrieving prior versions.">
- <desc0>No diff feature</desc0>
- <desc1>Revision Diffs with the latest</desc1>
- <desc2>Revision Diffs with the all</desc2>
- <comment>on wiki texts only</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="rollback" title="online supports for
retrieving/rollbacking to prior versions.">
- <desc0>No rollback feature</desc0>
- <desc1>rollback to the latest</desc1>
- <desc2>rollback to all</desc2>
- <comment>on wiki pages only</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="mergetools" title="tools to facilitate merge
pages/docs (of fully supported media).">
- <desc0>No such merging tools</desc0>
- <desc1>basic merge tools</desc1>
- <desc2>smart merge tools</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="picture" title="picture formats support">
- <desc>Supported means that the internal engine is able to store and
eventually make thumbnail/preview file</desc>
- <element name="commonpictureformat" title="common file format">
- <desc>Format are: jpg, gif, png, bmp, tiff, xpm, </desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>supported</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="commercialpictureformat" title="commercial formats">
- <desc>Format are: psp (PaintShopPro), psd (Photopshop)</desc>
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>supported</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="search" title="Support for search">
- <desc>The metadata and media content support is to be detailed in the
above metadata and mediasupport elements </desc>
- <element name="searchengine" title="Search Engine feature">
- <desc0>No search engine available</desc0>
- <desc1>Searches are limited (to filename, metadata or text content
for instance)</desc1>
- <desc2>Searches are feasable through most of the media content and
the metadata</desc2>
- <comment>the non fully supported format are not parsed in the
search</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="searchAPI" title="Search API for more detailed
searching in the contents and their meta-data">
- <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exist but is limited.</desc1>
- <desc2>This feature is fully powered</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="updatenotification" title="Support for new content or
update notifications">
- <element name="recentchanges" title="recent changes advertised on the
web interface">
- <desc0>No such features</desc0>
- <desc1>recent changes advertised according to the today's
date</desc1>
- <desc2>recent changes advertised only changes that happened since
user's last visit</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="rss" title="support for rss feed">
- <desc>Do detail the rss feed format/protocol in the comment
section</desc>
- <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>This feature exists and feeds are tunable and/or atom feeds
are available</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="othernotifications" title="support for other
notifications media">
- <desc>Do detail the media in the comment section</desc>
- <desc0>This feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists for one communication media</desc1>
- <desc2>This feature exists for several media: e.mail, and IM for
instance </desc2>
- <comment>easily do-able but not out of the bow</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="contentworkflow" title="Content management Workflow">
- <element name="simpleLock" title="Simple Lock mechanism">
- <desc>Ability to lock file avoid data lost or synchronization
issues</desc>
- <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature just exists</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists, and administrator can quickly unlock a
file from an user. A time out system exists to unlock file after a certain
amount of time.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="workflow" title="Content management workflow">
- <desc>Adding or updating a document in the system may be done
through a complex
- workflow. Do detail in the comment section</desc>
- <desc0>The feature doesn't exist</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature just exists, but the workflow is simple, a
single moderator system
- for instance</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists, and the workflow is tunable.</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="pluginsandpluginability" title="Plugins, pluginability,
built-in objects, and page templates">
- <element name="pluginability" title="plugin ability">
- <desc>adequate software architecture for custom plugin creation,
easy plugin interface
- for writing your own additions. Do detail in the comment section
the supported plugin languages </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support</desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="remoteAPI" title="XML/RPC Remote API">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>poor API</desc1>
- <desc2>rich API</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="webserviceplugin" title="web service plugin">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited integration capabilities</desc1>
- <desc2>good capabilities</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="feedagregation" title="ability to agregate feeds">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited integration capabilities</desc1>
- <desc2>good capabilities</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="builtinobjects" title="builtin objects or plugins">
- <element name="calendars" title="Calendars and Calendars events">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="blogs" title="blogs">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>A single blog is possible</desc1>
- <desc2>multiple blogs supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="polls" title="polls and vote editing and
publishing">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment>easily do-able but not out of the box</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="photoalbums" title="photo albums editing and
publishing">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="slideshows" title="slide show editing and launching
within the internet browser">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="bugtrackingintegration" title="Bug tracking system
integration (tickets linking and meta data extraction)">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited integration: tickets linking </desc1>
- <desc2>well supported: tickets linking and meta data
extraction</desc2>
- <comment>easily do-able but not out of the box</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="otherplugins" title="other noticeable built-in
plugins">
- <desc> others: FAQ, meeting minutes, Action Tracker plugin,
bookmarklet,
- Geolocalisation features: GeoURL or googleMaps plugins,
Tagging and Tag clouds
- (delicio.us, technorati, others), etc. Do list the plugins in
the comment section. </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>a few other plugins </desc1>
- <desc2>many other plugins</desc2>
- <comment>flickr, googlemap, etc...</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="wikipagelinks" title="wiki page creating, naming, linking,
listing and statistics">
- <element name="pagenaming" title="page creation/naming and linking">
- <desc> the wiki pages (or documents) can be viewed, created or edited
at anytime by
- anyone from a web browser (with certain limitations for
protected areas cf. the
- websecurity section ). </desc>
- <desc0>The wiki page are only created and accessible through
CamelCase links</desc0>
- <desc1>the wiki supports free links</desc1>
- <desc2>the wiki supports free links and image links</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="discussion" title="Each pages has a comments/discussions
area">
- <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>supported : access to a discussion/comment area particular to
that page</desc1>
- <desc2>fine grained discussion supported : possible to comment the
page by section</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="pagelists" title="wiki pages administration and
navigation lists">
- <element name="availablepageslisting" title="list of all available
pages">
- <desc> list of all the existing pages (and pages within the
hierarchy, if the
- hierarchy is supported, cf. webcontentmanagement section)
</desc>
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="backlinks" title="Backlinks: list of all the pages
linking back to the current one">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="undefinedpages" title="Undefined Pages : pages that
are referred to, but not yet created">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="orphanedpages" title="Orphaned Pages : not currently
referred to by any other page, thus meaning they are inaccessible through any
other means">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="lockedpages" title="Lock pages: currently hold for
editing pages, if the Lock is supported, cf. webcontentmanagement section">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="wantedpages" title="Wanted Pages: list of all the
pages wanted for creation by the users">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="mostleastpopularpages" title="Most/Least Popular
pages">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="recentlyvisitedpages" title="Recently visited pages">
- <desc0>The features does not exists</desc0>
- <desc1>The feature exists but is limited</desc1>
- <desc2>The feature exists and is complete</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="pageediting" title="page editing features">
- <element name="onlinepageediting" title="online page editing">
- <desc> All the pages (or documents) can edited at anytime by anyone
from a web browser,
- (with certain limitations for protected areas cf. the
websecurity section ). The
- following element details the editing features. </desc>
- <desc0>Not supported, it's not a wiki</desc0>
- <desc1>n.a. </desc1>
- <desc2>supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="i18nofdocuments" title="i18n of documents :
Internationalization and Multilingual capability for documents">
- <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support: unicode, nor Right-to-Left Support (as for
Hebrew and Arabic)
- are supported </desc1>
- <desc2>fully implemented</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="wikisyntax" title="wiki syntax or wikitext features">
- <desc> The following features list is supposed to show the ease of
learning and using:
- writing, reading and modifying wiki pages </desc>
- <comment></comment>
- <element name="lightweightmarkuplanguage" title="light weight markup
language support">
- <desc> the most known light weight markup language are : CREOLE
- (http://www.wikicreole.org/wiki/Home), BBCode
- (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode), Textile
-
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textile_%28markup_language%29), Markdown
- (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown), BBCode
- (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode), Radeox API
- (http://radeox.org/space/start) </desc>
- <desc0>this wiki has a very specific or very poor syntax</desc0>
- <desc1>this wiki has a uncommon or poor syntax </desc1>
- <desc2>this wiki support a standard and rich light weight markup
language</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="tableedition" title="Tables edition ease: simple and
complex (colspan and rowspan) table support">
- <desc0>not implemented</desc0>
- <desc1>implemented but with a limited API, simple tables
only</desc1>
- <desc2>implemented exhaustively, simple and complex (colspan and
rowspan) table
- support</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="htmltags" title="HTML Tags allowed">
- <desc0>not allowed</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support</desc1>
- <desc2>supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="toc" title="TOC (Table of content) Auto-generation">
- <desc0>not implemented</desc0>
- <desc1>implemented but with a poor API</desc1>
- <desc2>implemented exhaustively</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="wikicomments" title="Internal Comments / comments in
the wiki page code">
- <desc0>not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>n.a.</desc1>
- <desc2>supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="otherspecialsyntax" title="other specialized wiki
syntax">
- <desc> support for footnotes, quote, interwiki links, emoticon and
other icon rendering
- through syntax. Do list in the comment section. </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>a few other syntax/editing plugin </desc1>
- <desc2>many others</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="pageeditingusability" title="page editing Usability">
- <desc> Does the wiki provides the following features: Preview before
saving; Section
- Editing or whole page only editing; Double-Click on the text
to Edit; access Keys
- (to save, edit, quit ...) ; different editor are supported
(some with editing
- Toolbar); a fully WYSIWYG editor is available. Do detail the
available features in
- the comment section. </desc>
- <desc0>very limited features</desc0>
- <desc1>a few of those features are available</desc1>
- <desc2>all those features are available</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="spellchecker" title="spell checker">
- <desc>Useless feature if you use a decent browser like firefox2 that
contains an inline spell checking:
- a built-in spell checker enables users to quickly check the
spelling of text entered into Web forms
- (like this one) without having to use a seperate application.
- </desc>
- <desc0>no spell checker availble or it's just based on a too limited
dictionary that make it
- being a wast of time</desc0>
- <desc1>working dictionnary but limited (e.g: grammar not included,
false positive, hard to
- extend)</desc1>
- <desc2>Powerful dictionary</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="contentincludes" title="Content Includes : Inclusion of
pages inside another wiki page">
- <desc0>Not supported</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support</desc1>
- <desc2>supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="flagging" title="editing flags features : meta data added
by the commiters when editing">
- <desc> Those features are not that usefull when the
pagesversioncontrol is well
- designed, they can be things like: "Minor Changes flagging"
feature, or "Change
- Summary" features </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited features</desc1>
- <desc2>exhaustive features</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="advancededitingfeatures" title="Advanced editing
features">
- <element name="templating" title="MetaData Form and templating
ability">
- <desc> Design Engine for Meta-Data and Forms, allowing to design
custom forms with
- text fields, textarea fields, number fields, static select
fields API to display
- meta-data in view and edit mode inside the Wiki page. (to
create custom forms
- and templates and In-place (inline) editing of form
information in pages). </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited features</desc1>
- <desc2>exhaustive features with a rich API</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="codesyntaxhighlighting" title="Code Syntax
Highlighting">
- <desc> hightlight (colorize) source code snippets when added to a
wikipage </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>present but minimal</desc1>
- <desc2>very well supported: colorize according to code/language
specifications</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="mathformulas" title="support for Math formulas edition
and display">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported and standard : LaTeX syntac support: to
edit mathematical
- formulas in Latex syntax directly in the Wiki and display
them as images</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="tableplugins" title="plugins associated with wiki
table syntax">
- <element name="tablesorting" title="Table sorting plugin">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>0</score>
- </element>
- <element name="spreadsheet" title="Add spreadsheet formulae like
$SUM($ABOVE()) to tables">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="chartplugin" title="ChartPlugin : charts creation
from wiki tables">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>partially or poorly implemented </desc1>
- <desc2>well done</desc2>
- <comment>not officially released yet</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="media" title="media editing features">
- <desc> support for Image Editing (applet for instance) or other
media in-line editor
- (SVG, MindMap ...) </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>one or two editing capabilities like these </desc1>
- <desc2>many capabilities</desc2>
- <comment>svg and mindmap in progress</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </element>
- <element name="wikiscripting" title="scripting/programming ability
within the wiki page code">
- <desc> programming API to create custom dynamic web applications only
using the Wiki
- interface. Do detail in the comment section the supported wiki
scripting languages. </desc>
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited API </desc1>
- <desc2>rich API</desc2>
- <comment>groovy and velocity script ability</comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- </section>
- <section name="pagesexport" title="wiki pages exports">
- <desc> RSS feeds are already described in the webcontentmanagement
include/section. Here we
- list the other export kinds. </desc>
- <element name="rawexport" title="raw export: wiki page as coded">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support </desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="htmlexport" title="page HTML Export (without the wiki
navigation element)">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support </desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="xmlexport" title="page XML export">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support </desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment></comment>
- <score>2</score>
- </element>
- <element name="pdfexport" title="page PDF export">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support </desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment>a bit buggy</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- <element name="customoutput" title="custom output plugin-ability (RSS,
FOAF)">
- <desc0>No such feature</desc0>
- <desc1>limited support </desc1>
- <desc2>fully supported</desc2>
- <comment>in progress</comment>
- <score>1</score>
- </element>
- </section>
-</document>
\ No newline at end of file
| [Prev in Thread] |
Current Thread |
[Next in Thread] |
- [Qsos-commits] qsos/sheet/wiki wiki.qsos xwiki/xwiki-0.9.840.q...,
Francois Le Droff <=