Re: [Denemo-devel] Typesetting error re score with voices : help for denemo

[Richard Shann]

On Mon, 2019-06-24 at 21:25 +0000, Bill Goodman wrote:
> Hi Again,
> 
> I'm starting to experiment with using voices to get the polyphony
> effect I was look for.
> 
> The "Playback" feature thinks the score shown in the top half if the
> figure is fine---clicking Play produces the notes I'm expecting
> 
> But the Typesetting feature keeps saying something's very wrong.  Can
> you see what I've done wrong?
Well I can see that the first full bar in the second staff is marked in
blue, meaning it is too short a duration (only one half quarter note).
You may want to fill it with rests (as you have the upbeat), or perhaps
non-printing rests. 
You should be told about this if you run Score->Check Score

But that by itself wouldn't trigger the message from the LilyPond
typesetter. 
You can look in View->LilyPond - right click and re-typeset and report
the messages that LilyPond gives at the bottom. Or just email the
score, compressed.

Richard

> 
> 
> Thanks
> 
> Bill
> 
> 
> On Monday, June 24, 2019, 03:09:20 p.m. EDT, Bill Goodman <bill.goodm
> address@hidden> wrote:
> 
> 
> Thank you, Richard and Joe, for your helpful responses.  As I
> mentioned, I am making some progress, and I'll try to find and use
> that Command Center, which sounds like it will help.   Also, I was
> expecting that the "dots" issue was related to using different
> Voices, so I'll try to start get the hang of that area of the
> program.
> 
> Your point is interesting, in your earlier email, Richard, that I've
> been thinking along the lines of editing static, visual symbols,
> whereas your program has more of a process orientation.  I'll try to
> keep that perspective in mind.
> 
> Thanks for your offers for additional help if I get stuck.
> 
> Bill
> 
> On Monday, June 24, 2019, 04:27:05 a.m. EDT, Richard Shann <richard@r
> shann.plus.com> wrote:
> 
> 
> On Mon, 2019-06-24 at 08:56 +0100, Joe Wilkinson wrote:
> > Hi Bill,
> > Richard will doubtless answer, but presumably you have found the
> > Command Center (under View) which opens a separate window where you
> > can search for commands etc.
> > I typed in Arpeggio and (on the fourth item) it found what you
> want,
> > I imagine. plus previously, how to extend arpeggios across staffs
> and
> > other stuff which is way beyond my competence!
> > Good luck. It is a great piece of software.
> > Joe Wilkinson
> > 
> > On 23/06/2019 22:45, Bill Goodman wrote:
> > > Hi, are there other help resources for Denemo besides your online
> > > manual?  
> > > 
> > > Your program seems great...once I.eventually find a solution to a
> > > next problem,..
> > >   But I always feel as if the manual's not much  help when
> > > searching for a solution, and it's all trial and error. 
> > > 
> > > My latest specific questions include:
> > >   - Is there an arpeggio symbol (i..e. the wavy line next to a
> > > chord)?
> > >   -  How can you detach the notes in the same apparent chord--if,
> > > for example, one is dotted but the other is not dotted.   The
> > > dot/undot button seems to want to dot or undot both notes
> together
> > > ..
> 
> This is one you can't solve by searching in the Command Center, as it
> is a matter of overall design, not a single command. You have to
> think
> of an "apparent chord" as being an example of polyphony - two voices
> that have just "met" at some point having the same rhythm. Or in your
> case, not quite the same rhythm (dotted and not dotted).
> So what you need is to create an extra Voice - which can be empty in
> most places if you only have occasional real polyphony - and fill in
> the bar where the divergence occurs. You can either share out the
> chord
> notes between the two voices you have or put non-printing rests in
> the
> new voice until the chord where they diverge dotted-not-dotted and
> put
> the differently dotted note in the other voice. You may want then to
> use the "Differently Dotted Merge On" and off commands to make the
> notes share the same stem (ie merged)
> There is a lot more potential complexity to writing polyphonic music
> but you may not come up against that - if you do, please ask for
> help.
> The example (File->Open->Open Example->Keyboard Polyphony) shows some
> of the things needed for a score that has five different rhythms at
> one
> point.
> 
> > >     For some other problems I've figured out 'workarounds' but am
> > > not sure if I've discovered the 'official' solution.   (For
> > > example, I couldn't find an instruction to add a natural
> > > symbol.....but if a flat is expected by the key signature, then
> > > clicking for a sharpening has that effect.
> 
> I'm not sure what "clicking for a sharpening effect" is! There
> commands
> for Cautionary Accidental and Reminder Accidental
> which are in the Notes/Rests->Append/Edit Note menu. As Joe says, the
> Command Center is there to help get round the problem of the very
> large
> number of features that a fully-featured music typesetter must have.
> The only snag is you have to guess at the musical terms involved - in
> this case the musical term "accidental", But given that you cannot
> find
> a command because it seems to be lost amidst thousands of commands
> you
> can be confident that it will be there somewhere... so you are
> welcome
> to ask. 
> 
> (I've long wanted to add a "keywords" feature to the commands - each
> command would have a set of "keywords" attached to it by a human
> editor
> to cover the case where the name label or help text of a command
> happens not to include a word someone might search for. But
> volunteers
> to attach all the keywords are too thin on the ground, and life is
> too
> short :( )
> 
> HTH
> 
> 
> Richard
>