Re: Feature Suggestions for Jami [Android]

[Richard Troy]

Hi Jami folks,

I'm surprised at some of Randy's asks. I have no idea of Randy's 
experience but if he's not paying you handsomely a lot of those 
suggestions sure seem like time wasters to me - suitable for suggesting 
to a very well funded and large team on a product more mature than Jami, 
perhaps.
Even then, some of them, to my eye, are Nanny-State type asks that are 
completely impractical, either huge security risks to implement OR simply 
impossible on modern in-your-pocket (cell phone) computing - for example, 
a content blur feature? "NSFW?" Really? The LAST thing I'd want is that. 
You'd either consume ALL the resources on the phone just processing images 
to check content OR you'd open up all sorts of privacy, security and other 
risks if the content was sent elsewhere for analysis. Plus, you'd have to 
scan every image. And to what standard of morality? Women can't show their 
ankles or faces - those are "a thing" in some societies around the globe 
today. What about medical doctors?
Isn't it better if people just learn to be mature adults? And for those 
who can't manage it, I recommend just disabling image transmission all 
together - THAT is possible without all the implementation problems.
Further, what clueful person, on a product like this, asks for an "unsend" 
feature? Sorry, it's ALREADY SENT. Perhaps a few un-intended sends will 
wise a person up to the reality of life and perhaps follow the old wisdom 
"engage brain before opening mouth." In short; BE MORE CAREFUL. (OTOH, the 
UI should be mindful of people in challenging circumstances accidentally 
hitting any given interface item - broken screen? Using on a subway system 
and the car rocks? Sure, protect with an optional confirmation check where 
appropriate... But I'd HOPE that computer users today are savvy enough to 
know that un-send "is just not a thing."
I'd venture a guess that Randy here doesn't really know what he's asking 
for, OR is deep pocketed and intends to hand the development team a few 
million dollars. But if the latter, would his asks be communicated this 
way? I doubt it.
I'm only responding because figured that if someone is going to make such 
recommendations, maybe somebody else might want to chime in on them. So, 
these are of course:
Just my two cents,
Richard


On Sun, 29 Oct 2023, Randy Reyes wrote:

> Date: Sun, 29 Oct 2023 16:41:14 -0400
> From: Randy Reyes <randyreyesmedinapr@gmail.com>
> To: jami@gnu.org
> Subject: Feature Suggestions for Jami [Android]
>
> [Feature Suggestions]
>
> - Add MaterialYou UI Theme.
>
> - Optimize for Android 14 devices compatibility.
>
> - Optimize app GUI for Android Tablets
> - Work with Foldable Displays
>
> - Work with Displays with Notch
>
> - Try a adding system-wide picture-in-picture to video player. videos will
> hover over apps and can be adjusted in size or collapsed into the side of
> the display to continue playing in the background.
>
> - Add Fingerprint Login
>
> - Support QR Scans
>
> - Support latest Emojis, Gifs
>
> - Add Profanity filters for Business Group Chats.
>
> - Blur any NSFW content (pics / video).
>
> - Needs ability to edit and delete message feature.
>
> - Needs an unsend message option when pressing on text message.
>
> - when sharing a picture or video accidentally needs a remove option for
> that (removes for sender / recepient as well).
>
> - Add Reply underneath message responding to a specific message in an
> individual or group chat.
>
> - Work with Chrome OS
>
> - Work with WearOS devices.
Richard Troy, Chief Scientist
Science Tools Corporation
510-717-6942
rtroy@ScienceTools.com, http://ScienceTools.com/