octave-maintainers
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Octave poster


From: Fotios Kasolis
Subject: Re: Octave poster
Date: Sat, 2 Oct 2010 03:22:21 +0200

As a grump, I have a few complaints. Can you please write "C and C++"
instead of "C/C++"? Although C++ is supposedly a superset of C, that's
mostly marketing, and good C++ doesn't look very much like good C code
at all, they really are different languages, with different habits. As
someone who was raised on C++ but not C, the difference is very
striking to me, and saying "C/C++" makes it sound like they're a
single language or more closely related than they actually are.

That is more or less ok! (even if I m not convinced, the are blood related like mother to son)

My other grumpy complaint is how you portray "commercial". Octave
isn't necessarily uncommercial, and in fact, I think it could benefit
a lot if we could commercialise it. Octave could also wear a suit and
tie once in a while; we're not always unkempt smelly hippies. ;-) I
think it would be better if you were just explicit and say "high
compatibility with Matlab" instead of being euphemistic. The Octave
homepage doesn't shy away from saying Matlab's name. I don't know what
a proper icon would be, since perhaps there's a trademark problem if
you use the Matlab logo.

I have no reason to advertise matlab in whatever I do (after all they do not pay me!). And as you say this kind of information exists in Octave's page (so we advertise matlab there for free?) ... they are going to simply click the info link right bottom and they are going to see it. After all I do not want to lose my right to complain when people send mails like "In matlab I do this, why it does not exist in Octave?".

Regarding the icon you got me wrong! it is Octave that wears a suit and tie ;D.

But that's just me. It's good work, and I think I speak for many of us
when I say that I'm quite happy with the graphical design work you're
doing for Octave.

Thanks! I m happy too!

Btw, wanna get back on Agora? ;-)

Not yet (I think I reached the upper bound of efficiently absorbing information this period ;)

/Fotios


reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]