RE: [Bug-gne]Right/Wrong if editorship in GNE/Nupedia

[Tom Chance]

> My concern about GNE (and it *is* only a personal
> one) revolves round the
> lack of editorial influence, and the resulting
> dilution of content.  Having
> a dozen different views of Tiannamen Square is
> useful, likewise different
> sides in the evolution/creation argument. However,
> for me at any rate,
> there has to be a limit on what can easily
> degenerate into name calling.

I agree here, it could, if we had a "reply" or
"review" bit, very easily degenerate into a discussion
forum. So that is why I would suggest a very open
modertation on article submission (just to check its
not one big advert, and isn't just saying "contrary to
the crap article on x...") with no "block" button,
only an "accept" button. Also no "review" or "reply"
idea, because its just pointless, and will become a
forum for flaming.

Tom Chance

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get personalized email addresses from Yahoo! Mail - only $35 
a year!  http://personal.mail.yahoo.com/