Re: [Lilypond-auto] Issue 3307 in lilypond: Rest positions incorrect with non-standard line count

[lilypond]

Comment #46 on issue 3307 by address@hidden: Rest positions  
incorrect with non-standard line count
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=3307

Regarding comment #43
I just started a little private poll about Rest-positions in tablature  
adressed to all guitarists I know. Not sure who will reply, though, I'll  
post any relevant result.

Regarding default-staffs:
Using _specified_ voices your patch will put the whole rest dropping from  
the line on which the half rest sits.
With this code
{
   \voiceOne r1 r2 r
   \voiceTwo r1 r2 r
}
the attached image returns.
Again, I think it's wrong, because the whole rest _should_ drop from the  
line above, where the half rest is settled.
If the half rest is on the fifth line (with /voiceOne), the whole rest  
_needs_ a ledger line or r2 should be on the fourth line, at least in the  
default setting. I'd prefer the latter.
If the half rest is on the first (with \voice Two), the whole rest should  
drop from the second.
If Gould says different I don't follow her. And if this will be  
LilyPond-default I'll override the r1-position every time (in specified  
voices).

Clef-positioning:
Ok, I'll not insist further.
Though, I'll reject any score a composer/conductor wants me to play, using  
a standard clef like this.

Regarding comment #44
Including eigth rests in my positive comment was indeed intended!

Attachments:
        rest-position-patch.png  2.7 KB

--
You received this message because this project is configured to send all  
issue notifications to this address.
You may adjust your notification preferences at:
https://code.google.com/hosting/settings