Re: Fixes NoteColumn vs SpanBar collisions. (issue 5323062)

[address@hidden]

On Nov 1, 2011, at 9:44 AM, address@hidden wrote:

On 2011/11/01 08:25:48, mike_apollinemike.com wrote:

Given that the 0.6 skyline horizontal padding is,

according to the comment above it, only intended to block ledger lines

from

overlapping a bar line, I think that this blocking effect it has on

horizontal

spacing is an unintended side effect.  So, unless anyone has arguments

for why

the old behavior should be kept, I think this is an acceptable (and

even

desirable) consequence of this patch.

I have no clue about this issue at all, but reading this comment
triggered my keyword-based interferometer.

A principal reason for skyline horizontal padding was to avoid long
stemmed notes from adjacent staffgroups from interlocking.

While interlocking is usually desired between voices and reasonably
appropriate inside of a pianostaff staffgroup with default clefs (!!!!),
it is usually wrong between independent instruments and totally wrong
between broken lines.

Hey David,

The skyline-padding in question only applies to NonMusicalPaperColumns, so it wouldn't have a holistic effect on staff groups.

As for inter-lockitude, it looks like current master produces the same results as my patch for independent instruments (see attached - I don't see any difference between the two images).

Perhaps its worth reporting this as a bug, but the solution would come from another region of LilyPond (probably pure heights of spanners).

Cheers,

MS