[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinion
From: |
Janek Warchoł |
Subject: |
Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions? |
Date: |
Sun, 7 Apr 2013 11:24:01 +0200 |
2013/4/7 Ian Hulin <address@hidden>:
>
>> I'd prefer ClefOctavation (or maybe ClefOctaveShift) to
>> ClefModifier because it's clearer / more intuitive (at least to
>> me). ClefModifier could be misunderstood to refer to the shape of
>> the symbol.
>
> 1+
> The only numbers that make sense above or below clefs are ones
> referring to a whole number of octaves (8, 15 etc.)
I don't agree. Personally, i think that transposing instruments could
use the non-octave modifiers to make their transposition clearer.
Anyway, since we allow non-octave modifications, it's better to
reflect that in the naming.
Janek
- suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Janek Warchoł, 2013/04/05
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Marc Hohl, 2013/04/06
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, address@hidden, 2013/04/06
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, David Kastrup, 2013/04/06
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition -opinions?, Trevor Daniels, 2013/04/06
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Janek Warchoł, 2013/04/06
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Marc Hohl, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, pls, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, David Kastrup, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Ian Hulin, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?,
Janek Warchoł <=
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Thomas Morley, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, David Kastrup, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Thomas Morley, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, David Kastrup, 2013/04/08
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, pls, 2013/04/08
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, pls, 2013/04/08
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Thomas Morley, 2013/04/08
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Janek Warchoł, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, address@hidden, 2013/04/07
- Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?, Werner LEMBERG, 2013/04/08