Re: suggestion: change OctavateEight name to ClefTransposition - opinions?

[Thomas Morley]

2013/4/7 Ian Hulin <address@hidden>:

> The only numbers that make sense above or below clefs are ones
> referring to a whole number of octaves (8, 15 etc.)

I know at least one piece using a \clef "G_5"

"Chiton"
Uroš Roijko
Verlag Neue Musik, Berlin
NM 852

It's a piece for Solo-Guitar using  a three staves layout:
1. RhythimicStaff (alternating with PercussionStaff and normal Staff)
2. DynamicStaff with TimeSignatures, etc
3. Staff with \clef "G_8"

I don't have a scanner, I reproduced the clef using some LilyPond
(note the bracket!)
-> attached png

So it'd vote for ClefModifier.

-Harm

clef-5-mod.png
Description: PNG image