[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes
From: |
dak |
Subject: |
Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043) |
Date: |
Wed, 13 Nov 2013 13:22:07 +0000 |
On 2013/11/12 21:58:13, janek wrote:
2013/11/12 <address@hidden>:
> It still would not be fun in connection with TabStaff, not repeating
> string numbers and stuff, and such repetition is really not
feasible.
I don't understand what you mean here.
> Of course the problem is that we have to make a decision what to
> support:
>
> a) we don't commit ourselves either way: it is undefined what a pure
> duration after an intervening chord will do.
>
> b) just single pitches, no chords: that's what this patch proposes.
>
> c) also chords: this patch needs more work, supporting code must be
> written, Pitch_squash_engraver has to be changed etc etc.
>
> The problem is that with both options b) and c), we'll soonish have
> music depending on this behavior.
>
> I'm leaning towards a): tell people not to rely on particular
behavior
> after a chord for now.
This probably is a good idea. At least i prefer to a) over b).
Ok, I think we'll let this more or less get in in the current form (just
to get feedback) and I'll do a followup patch that will give a _warning_
when a raw duration is used after a chord. Basically this will mean
that you are not supposed to use
\new RhythmicStaff { 8 8 4 2 } but rather something like
\new RhythmicStaff \drummode { tamb 8 8 4 2 }
which also is nicer in midi. This would not affect any music commands
interpreting rhythms: the pitch insertion (which would then complain
about preceding chords) only runs during scorification.
I am going to rework the documentation/code examples appropriately; I
don't think that requires restarting the countdown (the examples make
fewer assumptions in that manner).
https://codereview.appspot.com/22120043/
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), (continued)
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), ckenneth721, 2013/11/10
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), ckenneth721, 2013/11/10
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), dak, 2013/11/10
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), dak, 2013/11/12
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), benko . pal, 2013/11/12
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043), dak, 2013/11/12
- Re: Isolated durations in music sequences now stand for unpitched notes (issue 22120043),
dak <=