Re: MIDI dynamics parsing error

[Simon Albrecht]

Am 20.05.2014 15:41, schrieb Knute Snortum:
> (Note: the above code still emits a warning: Programming error: 
> impossible or ambiguous (de) crescendo)
>
> One of the things I really liked about LilyPond was the ability to 
> compile sheet music and MIDI from the same source. It seems to me that 
> this behavior is getting away from that value. I would think that in 
> piano and choral music if you create a temporary voice, not only do 
> you want the original dynamic to carry over into the temporary, you 
> want any dynamic mark to carry over back into the original after the 
> temporary is over.
>
> If I understand you correctly, the only way to set a dynamic change 
> while temporary voices are active is to set the mark on one voice, set 
> and omit it on the other(s), and set and omit it on the original voice 
> once the temporary voices are done. This seems unnecessarily complex 
> for a situation that I would think happens many times.
Perhaps it’s possible to move the Dynamics_engraver and _performer to 
staff level for this purpose?

Best, Simon