Re: Accidentals in cadenzas after barlines

[Stephen MacNeil]

I agree \accidentalStyle is nice syntax. And i agree my example was over kill for the situation (But works). However I disagree, on Score vs Voice/Staff. If you need to change in and out of using accidentals for example in a book. Score works well.

Take this example
 
http://burrito.whatbox.ca:15263/imglnks/usimg/4/4b/IMSLP02260-Bach_-_BGA_-_BWV_1056.pdf

page 3

here is a quick typeset.

http://mglessons.com/lilypond/accid.pdf

If I want to switch in and out of styles I wouldn't put it in the layout block or global so the solution is "Score" I could however right it in each part that needs to be changed but that would be "rather weird". I jest of course. But that's my understanding of it -- Am i missing something?

Thanks

Stephen

>Apart from \accidentalStyle having a nicer syntax, I strongly suspect
>that you don't use the last argument correctly.  'Score implies that any
>temporary accidentals should hold for the whole score across all
>systems.  That would be kind of unusual.  Most accidentals hold
>per-Staff.  Piano accidentals may hold per PianoStaff, and there are
>also per-Voice accidentals.  But per-Score would be rather weird.

>--
>David Kastrup