[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: two slur beginning on a same note
From: |
Mats Bengtsson |
Subject: |
Re: two slur beginning on a same note |
Date: |
Tue, 20 Feb 2001 21:39:23 +0100 |
> Mats Bengtsson <address@hidden> writes:
>
> > produced the following kind of result
> >
> > |__________________|
> > |______________|
> >
> > instead of the desired
> >
> > |_______|
> > |_________________________|
> >
> > I consider this a serious bug!
>
> LilyPond refuses to start more than one slur at the same note, she
> should also refuse to start a slur if another one is still open. That
> would be better than the first picture above. Although you could
> consider the above a bug, neither example makes any sense to me (I can
> play legato only once), the bigger slur can only be a phrasing mark.
OK! However, I'm certain that sooner or later you'll find some
composer who has used three or more simultaneous ``slurs''
with some specific meaning. Therefore, I'd prefer a generic
solution - namely allowing for an arbitrary number of nested
slurs - than a specialized one with only two hard-coded levels
available.
Also, at least for us who mostly use Lilypond for new editions
of old music manuscripts, it's not always obvious if a curved bow
is a slur or a phrasing mark, so it's not obvious if we should
use () or \( \) in the Lilypond code (this is more a philosophical
problem, though, as long as both are typeset the same way).
/Mats
- two slur beginning on a same note, Olivier, 2001/02/11
- two slur beginning on a same note, Han-Wen Nienhuys, 2001/02/19
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Olivier, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Rune Zedeler, 2001/02/20
- Message not available
- Message not available
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Rune Zedeler, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Mats Bengtsson, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Han-Wen Nienhuys, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Jan Nieuwenhuizen, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note,
Mats Bengtsson <=
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Jan Nieuwenhuizen, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Mats Bengtsson, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Han-Wen Nienhuys, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Jan Nieuwenhuizen, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Jan Nieuwenhuizen, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, Mats Bengtsson, 2001/02/20
- Re: two slur beginning on a same note, David Raleigh Arnold, 2001/02/22