Re: [Fgs-bs] FEETURE request

[Desired Username]

--- tps12 <address@hidden> wrote:
> Games should have two kibitzing "channels," one for
> commenting on the 
> game itself and one for tangential discussions (the
> players, weekend 
> plans, general questions about go). Only the first
> would be saved in the 
> SGF. The two could also have different access
> controls, so that only one 
> or two "official" commentators can kibitz in the
> game record, while the 
> temporary channel could be used to ask questions.

1) How would access be controlled?  The gamers? 
Presumably everyone would be able to read the
"official" commentary.  And the officials able to read
the questions in the temp?  No, questions about that
game should be visible in the SGF for later
downloading.  This sounds like the shout/gshout
distinction.  Hard to enforce.

2) I don't remember my second thought.

3) This reminds me.  Someone who is censored by
another user shouldn't be able to comment in that
person's games, either.

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software
http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com